The game appears to be mostly story/character focused rather than sandbox focused, despite the insane attention to detail on traditional sandbox elements (for context, I've already completed the main campaign). In a lot of ways it feels like two disjoint teams worked to create the final product and the story/character team won out. Not sure if that's ultimately the root cause of the stated inconsistencies, but it could be a contributing factor.
I appologize for the derail. How does such a completion work? I ask because I regularly will play open world games that take me months to complete. There are always people who finish them within a few days or less, and post as such online. This game has been out for 3 days. Is this done by speedrunning the main quests? Spending every waking hour playing? Or is this just a short [main quest] game? What was the difficulty level? Did you complete most quests the first time without dying/failing? (I assume those are mechanics)
Even Howlongtobeat.com only has a couple of playthroughs logged with the main story average length amounting to 47 hours with "rushed" at 44. That means they probably just played the main missions non-stop along with an opinion that it is story based.
While I kinda see what you’re saying, I also think what your implying as a bad thing is why so many games still feel like games. And painfully so. When I can look at a thing and be like, ok that us only here because of X.
GTA has always done this but this is another level, where there is so many smaller details that do nothing more than make the world feel real.
Adding in things that don’t have a mechanical purpose. Something we have never seen to this degree.
It gives the world building behind the story that allows the story they wanted to tell to feel genuine.
Yeah it doesn't sound like anything truly new. San Andreas had the clothing shops and you could work out to upgrade your stats. GTA IV had the terrible "Roman wants to go darting" crap.
It sounds like they have just made these sidequest more varied and specific instead of the same restaurant trip every time.
This is just how GTA games are. And they obviously are still preparing for GTA 6 Online to launch early next year as that is main cash machine of this game and what people stick around for, and that is more create your own adventure/sandbox type of mode.
In my experience GTA 3, San Andreas , GTA IV and GTA V were all rather story heavy (a good thing imo) . Is this one even more story heavy, or is everybody just used to GTA online now? (Which I didn't play at all so I dont' really know).
I feel like this is up to the player. This reminds me of Assassin's Creed Odyssey. You could play it like a regular video game or step back and appreciate how it tried to beautifully replicate ancient Greece (with the flaws and limitations of video games of course).
In GTA's defense, the online game is very sandboxed focused. GTA V online is just a sandbox you can do some missions with your friends. GTA VI online, whenever it comes out, will probably be the same. I don't think the story team won out. Its just the economics of video games. No one has been able to replicate the success of The Sims, so its almost foolish to try. You can't really sell a game on this level to recoup the cost as just a sandbox, hence the 2 different modes. Not to mention, this is what GTA players expect.
The expected gameplay loop is you do a main mission, then go around exploring the new stuff that have been unlocked to get money/weapons/vehicles. The only problem I have with this is, you always unlock better stuff later anyway.
What fun would it be to have the game root out every emergent moment or bit of depth? It would be a 300 hour story with the pacing of snails screwing.
The whole point of GTA is that between missions and such you explore however your heart takes you. Running from some objectionable swamp folk I may have slightly robbed I ran into a damned Sasquatch! Later driving at night taking on the scenery I saw a car going nuts on the side of the road. I followed a trail of discarded clothes and found a… zaftig women suspended beneath a UFO in a beam of light. In the end I was abducted and lost time.
It’s a world you can get lost in, but also for the people disinclined to do so there’s a critical path.
I will always wonder what would have happened if I'd given that old meth head lady $1000 for more bad advice. Maybe it's good not to follow all possible paths. Maybe I'll run into her again after I get filthy rich.
This is a traditional-ish Rockstar problem. GTA 4 had the very same issue, and so did 5, to a lesser extent.
When a game attempts to up the production values on everything, it's natural that coherence has to go out the window, because there's just too much work going on at once. Rockstar has more success than, say, Ubi does with recent Assassin's Creed games, but at this kind of budget, the whole will always be worse than the sum of its parts.
In this case though, the parts are so expensive, that the whole is still quite good.
>The game appears to be mostly story/character focused rather than sandbox focused
Weird comment. The game is pretty long, so if you have already finished it, that means you literally went from main mission to main mission. You made that choice yourself.
The main game is out but I expect much more to be added to the game on the coming years, maybe even an arcade/sandbox mode, closer to the older games. If it follows the same route as GTA V the sandbox is just the base for the next DLCs/content to be added. Multiplayer will also be a huge thing in the next years. We can expect another decade of increments to the base game
If it's story/character focused, I'm wondering why they didn't add the option of using LLMs ... it could make it much more interesting at very little extra cost (for them).
This is some crazy shit, not getting me much into GTA6 hype but fun to read people do that.
I’m still so much into games I can complete over a weekend and then go to another when I have next free weekend ( which is unfortunately not every weekend anymore )
> In fact, I found a number of avian inaccuracies in just my first few hours of playtime. Certain species like Whooping Crane and Red-cockaded Woodpecker are common throughout the map, despite being endangered and threatened, respectively, in real life.
This is because the world of GTA is just better managed and nicer than real life, obviously.
In case you didn't know, "GTA" in the title is "Grand Theft Auto," a popular series of video games based around automobile theft and birdwatching. Saved you a click. Sorry if you were expecting an article about the Greater Toronto Area.
I also heard there was anger that the boyfriend performed caring acts for the partner. Getting flowers or fixing a sink was unacceptably simping for a woman.
San Andreas (2004) also had girlfriends that you had to keep happy by driving around and going to restaurants with them. I know it's not like fixing the sink, but it felt equally stupid.
The climate has shifted in a way that most of these things have become political, for the better or the worse. I was thinking of what the response to having a black protagonist would have been these days from both sides of the aisle.
Hilarious how many outlaw badboyz are having their outlaw badboy fantasies completely derailed by storyline nudges in a video game.
Go be an outlaw badboy and shoot some strippers dude. Nothing is stopping you except your own complete lack of actual outlaw badboyness, even in the outlaw badboy videogame lmfao!
GTA has always done this but this is another level, where there is so many smaller details that do nothing more than make the world feel real.
Adding in things that don’t have a mechanical purpose. Something we have never seen to this degree.
It gives the world building behind the story that allows the story they wanted to tell to feel genuine.
It sounds like they have just made these sidequest more varied and specific instead of the same restaurant trip every time.
In GTA's defense, the online game is very sandboxed focused. GTA V online is just a sandbox you can do some missions with your friends. GTA VI online, whenever it comes out, will probably be the same. I don't think the story team won out. Its just the economics of video games. No one has been able to replicate the success of The Sims, so its almost foolish to try. You can't really sell a game on this level to recoup the cost as just a sandbox, hence the 2 different modes. Not to mention, this is what GTA players expect.
The whole point of GTA is that between missions and such you explore however your heart takes you. Running from some objectionable swamp folk I may have slightly robbed I ran into a damned Sasquatch! Later driving at night taking on the scenery I saw a car going nuts on the side of the road. I followed a trail of discarded clothes and found a… zaftig women suspended beneath a UFO in a beam of light. In the end I was abducted and lost time.
It’s a world you can get lost in, but also for the people disinclined to do so there’s a critical path.
When a game attempts to up the production values on everything, it's natural that coherence has to go out the window, because there's just too much work going on at once. Rockstar has more success than, say, Ubi does with recent Assassin's Creed games, but at this kind of budget, the whole will always be worse than the sum of its parts.
In this case though, the parts are so expensive, that the whole is still quite good.
Weird comment. The game is pretty long, so if you have already finished it, that means you literally went from main mission to main mission. You made that choice yourself.
GTA 6 seems to have consumed a lot of the RDR2 mechanics for the wildlife, weather etc
Critics: 99/100
User score: 5.6/10.0
I was lucky enough to witness some IRL along the Ocala section of the Florida Trail. Behaviorally, they seem to have a bit of that corvid cleverness.
I’m still so much into games I can complete over a weekend and then go to another when I have next free weekend ( which is unfortunately not every weekend anymore )
This is because the world of GTA is just better managed and nicer than real life, obviously.
don't fix the sink if that makes it more fun for you
The climate has shifted in a way that most of these things have become political, for the better or the worse. I was thinking of what the response to having a black protagonist would have been these days from both sides of the aisle.
Redditors are actually arguing this is a nazi game because it allows you to shoot anyone besides white men
Not exaggerating.
Go be an outlaw badboy and shoot some strippers dude. Nothing is stopping you except your own complete lack of actual outlaw badboyness, even in the outlaw badboy videogame lmfao!