"Google made the surprise announcement two weeks ago, on Election Day, with executives saying they wanted to address teachers and parents’ concerns around AI in the classroom. Since then, communities across the country have protested Google’s tight hold on tech in many schools."
---------------
This policy has a "got to get them young" feel to it. Google seems to be more interested in hooking kids on their product than in letting educators do what's right for teaching. DuckDuckGo immediately offered an AI free version of their search as an alternative, putting the lie to any claims Google might make that it's difficult for them to do the same.
Google's executives are looking even more evil than usual on this file. They had better backtrack quickly.
Your gripes about teachers aside, google is less trustworthy because of their history of being deceptive and acting against users' best interest, not because they're less competent.
> now I’m implicitly asked by educators to trust them here?
To be fair, nobody is asking you to do anything. You can do whatever you want and trust whatever you want. And when you vote (and I hope that you do, because that is how the voice of The People gets heard), you can vote for whatever you want, along with everyone else.
This framing confuses me. Google has shifted its product to be a search engine with AI first. The request here is effectively that Google built and maintain a second version of their product with no front facing llm, and Google has declined to, correct?
It isn't like there is some second version of Google that Google is withholding from schools. However, there are search engines which don't use AI. Switching to those would probably do more than protests to get Google to switch its product roadmap.
Here is the part you are missing: Google sold Chromebooks and G Suite to schools for the last 15 years under the assurance that these things will improve education. Schools are now telling Google that Gemini is a serious problem for cheating and coursework, and Google's response is that they can't be bothered to put in a feature flag for this new feature that is causing problems. For institutions that have collectively spent tens of billions on locked down Google hardware, that is a thumb to the eye.
The most generous interpretation of Google's response is that Google's product suite is not aligned with the goals of educational institutions and that Google isn't willing to put in the work to get it there. The actual story of course is that Google is a monopoly that lobbied hard to get schools locked into their ecosystem and now they are pushing their weight around to try to get kids hooked on their AI early.
> The most generous interpretation of Google's response is that Google's product suite is not aligned with the goals of educational institutions and that Google isn't willing to put in the work to get it there.
This was my read. Google has turned on a dime, comparatively. Their search model has transformed completely.
Consider that the whole web was their partner, and it worked well for decades. But ai has shifted the ecosystem and google is cannibalizing the web and their prior search experience to build a closed agentic search experience instead.
My read is schools and school revenue simply aren't that important to Google relative to their overall revenue and more importantly, overall profit.
And it DOES suck for schools that want to go no ai and who made investments, to be clear.
Schools in their current form will not be around. The Ai is 10/10 more knowledgeable than teachers. Maybe I’m being too broad but this 100% certain for the US.
> The Ai is 10/10 more knowledgeable than teachers. Maybe I’m being too broad but this 100% certain for the US.
I think this comment makes it pretty clear that this is just your personal experience and absolutely cannot be applied to every single teacher in the US.
> Most spend 12 years in school and come out with no marketable skills. Something could be wrong with that.
You’re not wrong, but schools are only partly to blame for that. Plenty of other factors out there. Don’t make the mistake of blaming schooling for a broken economic system and what are fundamentally social class issues.
They are wrong. 17 year olds don't need marketable skills. They need experience, and an opportunity to build on their their substrate of general knowledge and deeply study one or two areas that interest them.
If school isn't delivering that, then yes, they are broken. But no-where in schooling is the requirement to deliver someone with "marketable skills".
> Most spend 12 years in school and come out with no marketable skills. Something could be wrong with that.
There's nothing wrong with that. That's the base for learning "marketable skills". 12 years gives you a solid grounding in basics, and you start to get an idea of what you're maybe good at, or interested in, and then you get the opportunity to diversify, to take that basic learning to university or college and study one or two specific things, or get some kind of entry-level/junior position.
17 year olds don't need "marketable skills". They need encouragement, opportunity, and experience.
And anyway, fuck your "marketable skills". Knitting is not a marketable skill, but you know what, it shows skill, application, and dedication. Not everything learned in school is marketable, and there's nothing wrong with that and everything wrong with thinking otherwise.
Otoh, you have to be a super dumb pragmatic moron if you let Google or Microsoft into your school. If you hear someone takes offense with this truth, tell them to focus on the 'pragmatic' qualification; I heard only goods things about that word.
Every widget on Google’s search page is an independent component maintained by different teams. There are thousands. Each one can be configured to trigger or not based on thousands of different switches (environment, product config, experiments, etc.)
It’s dead simple to turn off singular components in specific configs.
Right now, but once you contractually sell a "no AI" product then you need to maintain a version which has "no AI". The existing of a link form which has no AI presently is very different from a contractual commitment to institutional buyers who will complain loudly and sue if the contractual conditions are not met.
No you just let someone pay to be on an IP address list and when handling a request, if the client IP is on that list, you skip over the section of the code that generates the AI summary.
And if they get around the restriction or find a way to ai mode is Google contractually liable?
To feel confidant in the delivery I would expect Google to need to build and maintain a no-ai search engine, indefinitely, even if their current search experience becomes more ai-centric.
This was my point. I think Google knows their own project roadmap and doesn't want to contractually build and maintain a legacy no-ai version of search.
Do you have evidence of that? Because personally i would be very surprised that google is maintaining a non-AI version just for kicks and not using it anywhere. That is just not how tech companies operate.
No, Google still has a search engine that returns pages of results like it is 1999. The Gemini iframe (or whatever) sits on top of those pages of results.
This is just willfully misunderstanding what the schools want. It's very obvious they want the summary/chatbot interface to go away, and to only show links that are shown below the chatbox instead. Nobody is asking anyone to change the ranking.
This is not a particularly big ask. If it truly is lost science to not add a chatbox above the links, they could hide it it via the CSS layer if needs be. If nobody remains at google that knows how to hide a div with CSS, half the people in this comment thread could help them with that.
Their requirements are broader than the user interface. Some boards have policies to prevent students from using AI, or using student content for AI training. In other words, there can be no read or write pathways that include AI.
There is no reasonable way for Google to do that (that they could affordably sell to the schools).
>> This is just willfully misunderstanding what the schools want. It's very obvious they want the summary/chatbot interface to go away, and to only show links that are shown below the chatbox instead. Nobody is asking anyone to change the ranking.
> I think you are projecting your own desires onto the schools, and if that were actually what the schools wanted, it would not be an issue
It's pretty obvious you are wrong and the GP is correct.
If Google's ranking was done by AI for the last "12-15 years", the schools didn't care. But now Google adds a fucking chatbot that the kids can ask to do their homework, and that's when the schools start caring. It's pretty obvious the chatbot and AI overviews are what they care about.
Certainly it's a fact that the schools didn't care in the past, but I think that's mostly a result of AI not being in the spotlight then, and there wasn't a broad anti-AI faction then.
From TFA:
> Attendees of all ages held signs reading, “NO AI IN MY SCHOOL!”, “A.I. Gets an F,” “Stop stealing our imaginations,” and “SCHOOL Librarians = THE BEST Search Engines.”
I'm pretty sure these people would not be okay with plain search if they understood the extent to which it uses and has used AI.
(Also, I suspect you and other commenters have an implicit belief that the AI plain search uses and what the AI box does are fundamentally different, and I doubt that. The search algo is going to incorporate new tech as it comes along, and it's unlikely there is zero LLM involvement.)
> Certainly it's a fact that the schools didn't care in the past, but I think that's mostly a result of AI not being in the spotlight then, and there wasn't a broad anti-AI faction then.
> From TFA:
>> Attendees of all ages held signs reading, “NO AI IN MY SCHOOL!”, “A.I. Gets an F,” “Stop stealing our imaginations,” and “SCHOOL Librarians = THE BEST Search Engines.”
> I'm pretty sure these people would not be okay with plain search if they understood the extent to which it uses and has used AI.
I doubt it, and if they did, it'd probably be due to misunderstanding where they conflate LLMs with pre-LLM AI technology (e.g. the "12-15 years" tech that was used for Google Search ranking). The emotions are pretty clearly being driven by the current thing (LLMs and similar models).
I think you're making the mistake of interpreting their statements too literally, using definitions and interpretations that they simply don't share, to falsely twist their statements into embarrassing contradictions. You can use the word "AI" and they can use the word "AI" and you can both mean different things (or have some conceptual overlap but with significant differences).
> (Also, I suspect you and other commenters have an implicit belief that the AI plain search uses and what the AI box does are fundamentally different, and I doubt that. The search algo is going to incorporate new tech as it comes along, and it's unlikely there is zero LLM involvement.)
When they say AI, they are almost certainly referring to the chatbots, the AI overviews, etc. and excluding search, which has no user-obvious AI component. Being "but ackchyually" to try to turn their position on its head can be pretty disrespectful.
They have to maintain a web search engine regardless, because the LLM needs it. It's not just hallucinating facts from its weights. (I mean, occasionally it will do that, but usually it's based on search results.)
This isn't about maintaining the back end. It's about how the search results are presented.
> It's not just hallucinating facts from its weights. (I mean, occasionally it will do that
My experience is the Google AI block at the top of each search has very frequent hallucinations presumably caused by the fast model required so users don't scroll past it before it's finished loading.
Google sold this product to many schools during the pandemic. In my opinion, it is an epic fail on their part that they have ignored the needs of this market segment. That they now expect them to come up with their own solution to a problem that Google has created seems unreasonable to me.
This is a trivial change for Google. I worry that the rationale is that if they force-feed the AI summaries to children then those children are more likely to grow up into customers willing to purchase LLM products or be generally more willing to accept LLM content. Which is kind of gross.
The request is to make the visible bits (AI mode, AI overview) hidden. Schools don’t care if Google is using classical PageRank or AI-based ranking under the hood.
If customers are literally asking for a certain customization like this, I don't see why it's a crazy ask. I don't hate the AI features in Google but I think it makes sense to have a setting somewhere to disable it.
Couldn't they just turn off the generative summary and go back to showing search results instead? It doesn't seem like asking for too much additional from one of the world's largest and most capable companies.
Technically, perhaps, but the future is in LLM answers. The old style search is likely to rot as Google invests everything in the AI mode.
Or another perspective: Nobody expects to be able to ask Google for a version without ads, even though ads are annoying, because they know Google makes most of its revenue from search ads. Why do they then presume to dictate that Google give up on their strategic priority of pivoting to AI? It's equally absurd. Thankfully we have long had a solution for this: client-side blocking.
Ads pay for the product, and AI doesn't. It's absurd to ask them to burn money, it's not absurd to want a toggle for a new feature that causes problems.
And they'll fight back against blocking.
(Also asking for a version without ads is reasonable if you're willing to pay a modest fee for it. So that's not absurd either.)
Only if chrome supports the required extensions, which with a drop of manifest v2 they only do half assed. School boards can also filter at the network level but that's very hard to get right and can cause a whole new set of problems
SEO didn't force Google to ignore half your search terms or give you results for thematically or semantically similar search terms that are ultimately irrelevant to what you actually searched for.
That was all the doing of employees at Google. SEO did not have even the tiniest iota of relevance for Google's discretionary choice to make search results worse.
But even though they are worse, they are not yet useless.
> The request here is effectively that Google built and maintain a second version of their product with no front facing llm, and Google has declined to, correct?
Google already has a web search with no front-facing LLM, and you can get it by selecting "Web" from a search results page, or by including udm=web in a constructed search URL like so:
Somehow, it's impossible for Google to provide schools with the no-AI-summary search engine they already provide! My personal opinion of Google's behavior is in the example URL that I gave.
Are the schools explicitly asking for "no front-facing LLM"/"no AI-summary", or are they asking for "no AI"? Those are two very different things. Separate from the LLM-generated summaries, the basic Google Search results ranking have used various AI techniques for well over a decade. It should be easy for Google to turn off the summaries for specific organizations, but it's infeasible for them to go back to the pure Pagerank results from the 2000s.
> Are the schools explicitly asking for "no front-facing LLM"/"no AI-summary", or are they asking for "no AI"? Those are two very different things. Separate from the LLM-generated summaries, the basic Google Search results ranking have used various AI techniques for well over a decade
The first one. They've made that clear, and also, evidence over the past decade+ indicates they aren't concerned with the second one. And why would they be?
> Starting next year, Google said, its A.I.-related products, including Search and its Gemini app, will be turned off automatically for schools, and administrators can choose to turn those A.I. tools on. But there will be no version of search available without A.I. chatbot features, meaning schools that want to forgo A.I. will lose access to an important learning tool.
It's specifically chatbots that Google is saying they won't allow schools to disable without disabling search as a whole.
Or by including -whatever at the end of your search query... It's not a specific "-ai" parameter, AI isn't yet trained to answer negative queries so if Google sees a negative query it disables AI overview.
This is the dumbest strawman argument, and I can't believe people are still stooping to it to carry water for Google.
Schools do not care whether Google uses AI under the hood. They do not care whether Google sorts its results using AI.
They do want Gemini to stop answering student questions when they're typed into Google, and to stop giving summaries at the top.
The dumbest, working solution would be a one-line CSS fix to hide the Gemini box at the top of search results for schools. A smarter solution is easily within the grasp of Google.
Exactly. If the teacher asks the student a question and the computer does it for them, then what's the point? Your homework is to type this into Google and copy and paste what comes out.
What do people gain from being obtuse? You want to pretend to be confused even though you're probably smart enough not to be? It's very simple, people want the traditional list of links search results and not LLM-written overviews. It's not like that has been thrown away or isn't still in production.
The move is 100% punitive on the part of Google. From the recent CNN article:
"Google is rolling out new controls for schools to limit students’ access to the company’s AI tools. But if schools opt out of AI altogether, they’ll also lose access to Google Search."
They are saying that if schools would like to disable all of the AI tooling in the Chromebooks used by students then Google will also disable access to search.
>They are saying that if schools would like to disable all of the AI tooling in the Chromebooks used by students then Google will also disable access to search.
THAT is a clearer answer than any I received. If the demand is "let us turn off AI features generally, but keep search with AI" then that seems like an extremely reasonable request. I'm not sure if that is the request but it's not outlandish vs. maintaining a contractually provisioned no AI search engine version.
What they are aiming towards is irrelevant. Your argument could just as well be interpreted as "Google is trying to mandate students rely on AI summaries so Google can one day stop linking to websites that are not owned by Google".
If anything, this is an argument in favor of the schools and against Google.
If Google wasn't still linking to external websites then you might have a point. But they are. So what Google wants to "nudge" students to do is irrelevant when schools - the entity actually empowered to teach students - are asking them to hide an iframe when students are using search.
Until the day Google stops linking to the rest of the Internet, that will be the most trivial of asks.
> Google has shifted its product to be a search engine with AI first. The request here is effectively that Google built and maintain a second version of their product with no front facing llm
Guys, we're all programmers here. We all know this is the kind of bullshit engineers say when they don't want to do something. We don't have to fool each other.
I don't know how Google Search works, but I can guarantee you that they don't have LLM responses intrinsically linked to search results. If their LLM services go down, I'm pretty sure they can still serve search results. All that schools want is to have that flag exposed in the account/organization settings page.
This is the same type of bullshit Microslop tried to pull with Windows XP: saying that they can't unhook Internet Explorer from Windows. The EU forced them and it turned out it was possible all of a sudden.
Saying "maintain a second version" is so hyperbolic. All that's being asked for is making a flag public. A single Google engineer should be able to code it (even without AI) and deploy it in 2 hours worldwide.
I did a little research on this and it reminded me that even though Google generally stays out of the news (for bad things at least) they are still a giant corporation and are purely in it for profit, even if it's more lowkey. Forcing schools to have an AI feature enabled in ordered to use your product is not something I can agree with I'm afraid.
As someone with a teenager who has a chromebook issued by the school district I am very confused by this article. The IT department at my son’s school has clearly done something to his chromebook, when he searches Google an ai overview does not appear. Ever. There are no ai tools on his Chromebook. Is this a phased rollout over larger districts? The article does not provide enough information for me to make any assumptions especially when the core argument doesn’t resonate with my reality. Not only does his Chromebook not show Gemini the ethos (at least in my area) is that students don’t want to use AI. In fact, when reading anti ai sentiment on HN I’m often reminded of his discourse. That is not to say kids won’t try to to cheat; but while some try: when a 15 year old tries to submit homework written by an AI the teacher can spot it from a 100 mile distance. Getting these kids to read anything longer than a sentence is almost impossible. So many of the other kids in his class have exceptionally low literacy rates and emotional problems (which seem to be brought about by the combination of Covid + iPad parenting) that I would argue AI usage is a low ranking issue. In fact I would go further and say if the AI can write something they are willing to read maybe we should just let them. The world for them won’t look anything like the world we grew up in and while (if true) I would be very angry that Google is pulling their support for students I think this isn’t that and that there is a strong anti ai political aspect to this story which I believe is overstated
I cannot stand the Chromebooks. I wish they would kill them off. My kids got them as well but they at least still use text books. They are not using them at home though. They got steam decks attached to a screen for their gaming computers and its made the install mods and other stuff actually learning some computing.
Can someone help me understand why can't the schools install another browser? Or default to another search engine? I thought that this was possible on chromebooks. While I understand that this may be a second best solution, can't the IT staff at the school boards implement these solutions?
K-12 IT employee here, I lurk HN a lot and made an account to throw in my 2 cents.
Anyway, both are generally true. My district uses a hub model, where support staff are dispatched out to schools and network infrastructure/business ops are centrally managed. But our model is common to larger districts; smaller ones often rely on small general-purpose IT teams - maybe a handful of people.
Obviously, being both public-sector and education, the pay isn't great because the funding isn't there. I like to think most of my colleagues are competent, service-minded people, we're just understaffed. We don't usually experience a lot of turnover, just growth from 2020-2024, but the economy has made some folks reluctantly move on lately. I'm hiring now and the strongest candidates withdrew when they realized what our salaries were. We're in a metropolitan area - rural districts have even weaker candidate pools and lower funding.
My district's leadership has embraced AI as part of our students' future, so they're taking an "allow it, but regulate it" approach and Google's change doesn't impact us. I have mixed feelings about how tech is integrated in grade schools in general, but this _is_ something of an added burden to workaround for under-resourced districts who don't want it.
I used to work at a state college and during a major tech turnover we had 1 tech employee for 3 campuses across 3 counties. That 1 was me. 5000 students, hundreds of staff, and me keeping the lights on for 3 years.
The instant someone offered me $1 more an hour I quit.
Its not like there aren't other options. It seems unreasonable that a user who (presumably) isn't paying should be able to dictate product decisions. If you dont like google's decisions, vote with your feet.
I don't Google for answers as much as Google seems to think I should. I often Google to navigate the web but they are making this actively harder. Plus their LLM answers are frequently either missing the point or flat out wrong. I feel bad for those that will grow up taking the generative AI answers as verbatim because they do not know better. Though there is some hope, some kids I've talked to have been taught to distrust LLMs and to ignore or not trust AI results - so at least we have that.
I haven't worked there in years but the visible heads of the AWU include some of the most clueless, dysfunctional people I have ever encountered and did not seem to me to represent anything resembling the central position of the typical Googler.
AWU is an unserious organization and absolutely does not have its act together. They seem ambivalent toward recruiting enough members to actually gain worker bargaining power (which like, isn't that the primary mechanism and purpose of a union?). Even before they have that power they want to charge you 1% of your salary to print t shirts and hold solidarity with contractors basically - the cart comes before the horse. This is literally just strongly worded letter without that power. Doesn't mean nothing will come of it (I hope it does much like the voluntary exit program), but if it is resolved, it will likely be due more to the larger outcry and only in very small part to AWU itself (again like the voluntary exit program). Very expensive socialist social club otherwise.
i don’t understand, what is Google if not their employees?
i know i know, I’m being deliberately obtuse, but I just hate this notion that people are just employees and they throw their hands in the air or shift blame to management.
if you are an employee you are responsible to the eyes of the people
And which would you propose? There's no search engine I know of that isn't run by some kind of profit-seeking corporation. And that's probably a good thing, since we all know what public sector funding for libraries ends up looking like.
In related news, Google punishes several employees for insubordination. Didn't they learn their lesson when this exact same thing happened with the Palestine cause?
It seems like a pretty simple idea for schools to just switch to ddg or bing if they choose to keep their students ignorant of AI until it replaces them.
Plus I don't get the point of petitioning a business to do something, it ain't a charity.
1. People petition businesses all the time, especially when the business has a monopoly. Besides regulations, things like the MPAA,ESRB, and even just Xbox backing down on some anti-consumer changes all are the result or (consequence if involuntary) of this.
2. Google absolutely behaving nominally charitably around schools. The strategy around things like Chromebooks may have a well troded ulterior motive but that isn't on the books.
It's frustrating because you have to commit a non-negligible amount of your paycheck to the union and then it seems like this particular union (AWU) spends most of their effort helping non google employees (vendors, extended workforce, contract workers etc) negotiate what they want. I think if they thinned out their expenses to require lower fees and focused on larger issues it would be much more effective and have larger bargaining power.
They need 50% + 1 percent of the bargaining unit. Including others (vendors, extended workforce, contractors) in that not only makes it so that you need more people, but also that those individuals have conflicting goals which the union cannot represent (FTEs may have a workplace issue that conflicts with vendors).
As such, it cannot be a union registered with the NRLB and so will never have the bargaining power.
If it was instead a single group (e.g. subcontractors working for Google Fiber) then it would be easier to get the 50% vote and would have a single focus and could be a union that has collective bargaining power.
As someone who spent a fair amount of time at Google trying to get people to join the union, this is 100% true. Almost everyone who I asked about it cited union dues as their main concern. Extremely frustrating.
Perhaps it would be easier for the union to get people to join if it did things that would actually benefit them instead of basically being a PAC for the omnicause, supporting things that directly oppose employee interests.
Well I guess 1% of pretax income is non-negligible depending on what you get out of it. If its a worthy cause sure, I probably donate closer to 2% every year to various things.
When it's a charitable donation to fund labor lawyers and organizers for employees of Accenture and Cognizant, its a no for me.
lol, the AWU is a joke. As a sibling comment pointed out, it's a PAC disguised as a union.
A quick look at the demographics of their members page and comparing it with the demographics of the average Google employee will tell you why.
Maybe unpopular opinion, but unions should focus on improving working conditions, wages, and protecting workers from retaliation or unfair dealing not trying to influence the direction of the business. If a union were to push for the issue in TFA and it turns out to be the wrong decision, who is responsible? Will the workers take a voluntary pay cut to compensate for lost revenue? It also gives the executives another scapegoat if things do blow up.
In Japan (maybe other nations), unions can have a seat on the Board. They advocate for the employees, but as stakeholders in the enterprise, which I think is smart.
Not everybody knows this but you can actually have collective bargaining without the world ending.
I think the key difference for countries outside the US is they have stronger national cohesion and stronger national identity. The US is a country of immigrants (always has been, always will be, literally) and so it's harder to feel solidarity.
The US has an extremely strong national identity. The problem the US has is that everyone considers themselves to be a temporarily embarrassed millionaire.
The exploited underclass don’t see themselves as the exploited underclass, and so they have no desire to band together to improve their situation. They believe that they too will become rich if they continue to play the game they’ve been told to play.
>unions should focus on improving working conditions, wages, and protecting workers from retaliation or unfair dealing not trying to influence the direction of the business.
There is precedent for this in Germany, at least, though I don't know anything other than it exists.
> If a union were to push for the issue in TFA and it turns out to be the wrong decision, who is responsible? Will the workers take a voluntary pay cut to compensate for lost revenue?
If the executives make the wrong choice, it's already the workers who will make up for it with an involuntary pay cut or layoffs.
"Maybe unpopular opinion, but unions should focus on improving working conditions, wages, and protecting workers from retaliation or unfair dealing not trying to influence the direction of the business."
That is the bulk of what union workers are doing every day through their unions.
That doesn't mean unions shouldn't try to intervene on issues of broader concern as well. It's not a zero-sum game.
Google _has_ a union, as others have pointed out. Unfortunately they're too busy virtue signalling and tilting at windmills i.e., doing everything but looking after employees' needs, which, AIUI, is the main purpose of an employee union.
Layoffs, forced "VEP"s, etc. are happening all over Google, but the union is more concerned about Gaza, Palestine, etc.
This seems like a reasonable stance and not an impossible one to defend. Google is making a bet that long term, everyone will use AI. I think that's undeniably true.
The friction here is that they don't want to bifurcate their main offers to maintain an "AI free" experience, because the thesis is this won't exist long term. I think this makes sense.
This is not opposed to telling employees not to "punish schools", whatever that means. Nobody is being punished, they're just not being catered to.
No, Google has made a bet that forcing people to see AI search results will somehow be good for them. The moment the AI search results appeared, people asked for a way to turn it off. The answer was no.
They're not the only company refusing to let people turn off AI features people don't want. In this case, it doesn't appear to matter what the customers want.
I don't really see a problem here. Google has the right to design their product how they want to, and users have the right to stop using it if they don't like the product anymore.
The claim that "customers don't want this" isn't backed up by data. What percent of customers don't want it? What percent of customers actually do want these features and use them all the time?
A major municipal entity in a major municipality, we're talking about the entire population of their remit when we discuss customer impact. But focusing on something like 'percentage of total users' ignores the critical 'user value' dimension.
Google Search has 5 billion monthly users. I would be surprised if anti-AI users were even close to 50M, i.e. it's likely far less than 1% of the userbase. But if you want to make that argument, I would be interested to hear it.
I cede that some percent of Google's users are anti-AI, because that's obvious. What I want is for the person making a claim to be specific about what they're claiming. Are we talking about 50% of users, 1%, or 0.001%?
You do realize that Google would be the only organization capable of getting that data definitively right? And they have zero incentive to ask the question?
Actually, they do have the right to do that. Companies do it all the time, that's how we get better products. Or they run the product into the ground and the users move on to better things. That's how the process of innovation through competition works.
That would have been nice before they obtained the entire market, but I guess school districts can just switch and retrain over the weekend? Schools have tons of money too so they can dump all those chrome books and buy iPads.
They have what would have been regulated away as a monopoly when there was an appetite for that kind of fight. It's an analogy, not a metaphor.
There are so few competitors because Google has systematically starved them or bought them, so that it is practically impossible for anyone to compete with them on product or reach.
I have to disagree on the punishing aspect. They enabled Gemini for student accounts and there was a significant backlash. They then added some configuration so that schools can disable AI features, stating that if all AI features are disabled then they will _also_ disable Google search.
If they didn't want it to sound punitive, another solution might have been more appropriate. Google search today has a "Web" item (listed under "More" at the top of the page) which does provide search reasults without the AI overview. I think this indicates that this feature isn't so difficult to provide to schools, their paying customers.
No, even if the schools enable AI, it doesn't always show up on search. But it's a bet on people using it far more than they do today, which seems right. We're already past the tipping point where frontier models are more helpful than search engines for information retrieval, and soon that will be distilled down into ultra cheap models and nobody except Luddites will keep insisting on doing searches manually.
I think the Luddites have a case because LLMs are irrelevant to the "search is your address bar" use case. Google took off when it became easier and faster than remembering the URL when you had a specific page in mind. The AI-summary contributes nothing to this except moving the link you want to click on several centimetres down the screen.
Maybe don't frame everyone whose not a FOMO AI booster as a Luddite? Some of us want balance and nuance, and to treat AI as normal technology.
It's mildly insulting and if you know your history, inaccurate.
Personally, I'm hoping that once the FOMO AI boosters throw around the term 'Luddite' enough it'll become a positive term praising people who carefully evaluate risks/benefits of new technology instead of thoughtlessly chasing the FOMO.
I’ll type a one word search term to find a site, the result I want will be at the top, and Gemini will pump out a completely irrelevant half-page summary about something completely unrelated to what I was looking for.
Luddites had a good political position, and their demands were reasonable. Of course, the capitalist classes used the power of the state to put them down with violence, because police exist to protect the property of the wealthy, not to actually support justice.
There are many things called "AI". Smart search ranking driven by machine learning that helps me find relevant original content written by real people is one. LLM-generated slop is another. More of the first, less of the second, please.
But google has always been an AI overview. Google filters out things you think don't matter - that's AI. Google judges what pages are useful and which ones are trolls - that's AI. Google analyzes your search and decides how to interpret the terms to bring you the most "relevant" pages in the context you're asking from - that's AI.
Google is AI to the very core, to the very marrow of its bones, and it always has been. It wasn't always llm, but to pretend Google isn't AI is just ignoring the statue and staring at the fig leaf and thinking that's the product.
You know what "the AI overview div" means. Arguing about whether the rest of google counts as "AI overview" if you squint hard enough is a distraction at best. The div, the one at the top, the one with an LLM and a reply box, that's the div.
Which is perfectly sensible, both for the schools (get peanut butter from somewhere else) and the manufacturer (believes mayonnaise is more profitable than peanut butter). I don’t know why the manufacturer’s employees need to lobby the manufacturer to sell a product the manufacturer doesn’t want to sell.
Even that would be significantly more defensible for the manufacturer. They don't make it anymore, that sucks but gotta move on.
It's more like the bottom half of the jar is the same amount of peanut butter as ever and then they add a big squirt of mayo on top. They still make the old product as part of the bundle, and the bundle is the same price, but they insist on only having the bundle.
---------------
This policy has a "got to get them young" feel to it. Google seems to be more interested in hooking kids on their product than in letting educators do what's right for teaching. DuckDuckGo immediately offered an AI free version of their search as an alternative, putting the lie to any claims Google might make that it's difficult for them to do the same.
Google's executives are looking even more evil than usual on this file. They had better backtrack quickly.
> now I’m implicitly asked by educators to trust them here?
To be fair, nobody is asking you to do anything. You can do whatever you want and trust whatever you want. And when you vote (and I hope that you do, because that is how the voice of The People gets heard), you can vote for whatever you want, along with everyone else.
It isn't like there is some second version of Google that Google is withholding from schools. However, there are search engines which don't use AI. Switching to those would probably do more than protests to get Google to switch its product roadmap.
The most generous interpretation of Google's response is that Google's product suite is not aligned with the goals of educational institutions and that Google isn't willing to put in the work to get it there. The actual story of course is that Google is a monopoly that lobbied hard to get schools locked into their ecosystem and now they are pushing their weight around to try to get kids hooked on their AI early.
This was my read. Google has turned on a dime, comparatively. Their search model has transformed completely.
Consider that the whole web was their partner, and it worked well for decades. But ai has shifted the ecosystem and google is cannibalizing the web and their prior search experience to build a closed agentic search experience instead.
My read is schools and school revenue simply aren't that important to Google relative to their overall revenue and more importantly, overall profit.
And it DOES suck for schools that want to go no ai and who made investments, to be clear.
I think this comment makes it pretty clear that this is just your personal experience and absolutely cannot be applied to every single teacher in the US.
But I'm CHOOSING what I want to learn. Or learning what's required to solve real world problems that matter to my success.
Schools are DICTATING what students learn, more often than not. And children will escape being controlled when possible.
The educational model is broken. It was broken when it was invented.
Real learning is very different. It's the most powerful thing humans do and our system stifles, bores and turns off a lot of children.
Most spend 12 years in school and come out with no marketable skills. Something could be wrong with that.
You’re not wrong, but schools are only partly to blame for that. Plenty of other factors out there. Don’t make the mistake of blaming schooling for a broken economic system and what are fundamentally social class issues.
If school isn't delivering that, then yes, they are broken. But no-where in schooling is the requirement to deliver someone with "marketable skills".
There's nothing wrong with that. That's the base for learning "marketable skills". 12 years gives you a solid grounding in basics, and you start to get an idea of what you're maybe good at, or interested in, and then you get the opportunity to diversify, to take that basic learning to university or college and study one or two specific things, or get some kind of entry-level/junior position.
17 year olds don't need "marketable skills". They need encouragement, opportunity, and experience.
And anyway, fuck your "marketable skills". Knitting is not a marketable skill, but you know what, it shows skill, application, and dedication. Not everything learned in school is marketable, and there's nothing wrong with that and everything wrong with thinking otherwise.
It’s dead simple to turn off singular components in specific configs.
Source: Worked on a search team
To feel confidant in the delivery I would expect Google to need to build and maintain a no-ai search engine, indefinitely, even if their current search experience becomes more ai-centric.
This was my point. I think Google knows their own project roadmap and doesn't want to contractually build and maintain a legacy no-ai version of search.
But I guess they might stop selling search and just sell ai?
This is literally exactly what is happening.
It is exactly how Google operates, they have a high-level classifier that runs on every search query to determine which widgets show up on the page.
The idea of a pure Page-Rank ™ Google search is long gone.
This is not a particularly big ask. If it truly is lost science to not add a chatbox above the links, they could hide it it via the CSS layer if needs be. If nobody remains at google that knows how to hide a div with CSS, half the people in this comment thread could help them with that.
There is no reasonable way for Google to do that (that they could affordably sell to the schools).
> I think you are projecting your own desires onto the schools, and if that were actually what the schools wanted, it would not be an issue
It's pretty obvious you are wrong and the GP is correct.
If Google's ranking was done by AI for the last "12-15 years", the schools didn't care. But now Google adds a fucking chatbot that the kids can ask to do their homework, and that's when the schools start caring. It's pretty obvious the chatbot and AI overviews are what they care about.
From TFA:
> Attendees of all ages held signs reading, “NO AI IN MY SCHOOL!”, “A.I. Gets an F,” “Stop stealing our imaginations,” and “SCHOOL Librarians = THE BEST Search Engines.”
I'm pretty sure these people would not be okay with plain search if they understood the extent to which it uses and has used AI.
(Also, I suspect you and other commenters have an implicit belief that the AI plain search uses and what the AI box does are fundamentally different, and I doubt that. The search algo is going to incorporate new tech as it comes along, and it's unlikely there is zero LLM involvement.)
> From TFA:
>> Attendees of all ages held signs reading, “NO AI IN MY SCHOOL!”, “A.I. Gets an F,” “Stop stealing our imaginations,” and “SCHOOL Librarians = THE BEST Search Engines.”
> I'm pretty sure these people would not be okay with plain search if they understood the extent to which it uses and has used AI.
I doubt it, and if they did, it'd probably be due to misunderstanding where they conflate LLMs with pre-LLM AI technology (e.g. the "12-15 years" tech that was used for Google Search ranking). The emotions are pretty clearly being driven by the current thing (LLMs and similar models).
I think you're making the mistake of interpreting their statements too literally, using definitions and interpretations that they simply don't share, to falsely twist their statements into embarrassing contradictions. You can use the word "AI" and they can use the word "AI" and you can both mean different things (or have some conceptual overlap but with significant differences).
> (Also, I suspect you and other commenters have an implicit belief that the AI plain search uses and what the AI box does are fundamentally different, and I doubt that. The search algo is going to incorporate new tech as it comes along, and it's unlikely there is zero LLM involvement.)
When they say AI, they are almost certainly referring to the chatbots, the AI overviews, etc. and excluding search, which has no user-obvious AI component. Being "but ackchyually" to try to turn their position on its head can be pretty disrespectful.
They want to disable student access to the large language model Gemini.
This isn't about maintaining the back end. It's about how the search results are presented.
My experience is the Google AI block at the top of each search has very frequent hallucinations presumably caused by the fast model required so users don't scroll past it before it's finished loading.
This is a trivial change for Google. I worry that the rationale is that if they force-feed the AI summaries to children then those children are more likely to grow up into customers willing to purchase LLM products or be generally more willing to accept LLM content. Which is kind of gross.
I only have a cursory familiarity of this story, but isn't https://www.google.com/search?q=foo&udm=web already a "version of their product with no front facing llm"?
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/18/technology/google-gemini-...
Although “discussing alternatives” is an incredibly modest step away from Google.
Or another perspective: Nobody expects to be able to ask Google for a version without ads, even though ads are annoying, because they know Google makes most of its revenue from search ads. Why do they then presume to dictate that Google give up on their strategic priority of pivoting to AI? It's equally absurd. Thankfully we have long had a solution for this: client-side blocking.
And they'll fight back against blocking.
(Also asking for a version without ads is reasonable if you're willing to pay a modest fee for it. So that's not absurd either.)
But thats my assumption, so I might well be wrong.
SEO didn't force Google to ignore half your search terms or give you results for thematically or semantically similar search terms that are ultimately irrelevant to what you actually searched for.
That was all the doing of employees at Google. SEO did not have even the tiniest iota of relevance for Google's discretionary choice to make search results worse.
But even though they are worse, they are not yet useless.
Google already has a web search with no front-facing LLM, and you can get it by selecting "Web" from a search results page, or by including udm=web in a constructed search URL like so:
https://www.google.com/search?q=deliberately+obtuse&udm=web
Somehow, it's impossible for Google to provide schools with the no-AI-summary search engine they already provide! My personal opinion of Google's behavior is in the example URL that I gave.
The first one. They've made that clear, and also, evidence over the past decade+ indicates they aren't concerned with the second one. And why would they be?
> Starting next year, Google said, its A.I.-related products, including Search and its Gemini app, will be turned off automatically for schools, and administrators can choose to turn those A.I. tools on. But there will be no version of search available without A.I. chatbot features, meaning schools that want to forgo A.I. will lose access to an important learning tool.
It's specifically chatbots that Google is saying they won't allow schools to disable without disabling search as a whole.
Compare:
https://www.google.com/search?q=deliberately+obtuse
https://www.google.com/search?q=deliberately+obtuse&udm=web
This is interesting.
Schools do not care whether Google uses AI under the hood. They do not care whether Google sorts its results using AI.
They do want Gemini to stop answering student questions when they're typed into Google, and to stop giving summaries at the top.
The dumbest, working solution would be a one-line CSS fix to hide the Gemini box at the top of search results for schools. A smarter solution is easily within the grasp of Google.
They seem to be saying that Google is taking some punitive action directed at schools that don't adopt AI.
Whereas Google is actually just making an AI-only search product.
"Google is rolling out new controls for schools to limit students’ access to the company’s AI tools. But if schools opt out of AI altogether, they’ll also lose access to Google Search."
They are saying that if schools would like to disable all of the AI tooling in the Chromebooks used by students then Google will also disable access to search.
THAT is a clearer answer than any I received. If the demand is "let us turn off AI features generally, but keep search with AI" then that seems like an extremely reasonable request. I'm not sure if that is the request but it's not outlandish vs. maintaining a contractually provisioned no AI search engine version.
What they are aiming towards is irrelevant. Your argument could just as well be interpreted as "Google is trying to mandate students rely on AI summaries so Google can one day stop linking to websites that are not owned by Google".
If anything, this is an argument in favor of the schools and against Google.
If Google wasn't still linking to external websites then you might have a point. But they are. So what Google wants to "nudge" students to do is irrelevant when schools - the entity actually empowered to teach students - are asking them to hide an iframe when students are using search.
Until the day Google stops linking to the rest of the Internet, that will be the most trivial of asks.
Guys, we're all programmers here. We all know this is the kind of bullshit engineers say when they don't want to do something. We don't have to fool each other.
I don't know how Google Search works, but I can guarantee you that they don't have LLM responses intrinsically linked to search results. If their LLM services go down, I'm pretty sure they can still serve search results. All that schools want is to have that flag exposed in the account/organization settings page.
This is the same type of bullshit Microslop tried to pull with Windows XP: saying that they can't unhook Internet Explorer from Windows. The EU forced them and it turned out it was possible all of a sudden.
Saying "maintain a second version" is so hyperbolic. All that's being asked for is making a flag public. A single Google engineer should be able to code it (even without AI) and deploy it in 2 hours worldwide.
> we're all programmers here
Although I’m not I’ve been served the B of the A/B test: no summary at the top. (I avoid Google a bit but this is as recently as ~last month.)
Anyway, both are generally true. My district uses a hub model, where support staff are dispatched out to schools and network infrastructure/business ops are centrally managed. But our model is common to larger districts; smaller ones often rely on small general-purpose IT teams - maybe a handful of people.
Obviously, being both public-sector and education, the pay isn't great because the funding isn't there. I like to think most of my colleagues are competent, service-minded people, we're just understaffed. We don't usually experience a lot of turnover, just growth from 2020-2024, but the economy has made some folks reluctantly move on lately. I'm hiring now and the strongest candidates withdrew when they realized what our salaries were. We're in a metropolitan area - rural districts have even weaker candidate pools and lower funding.
My district's leadership has embraced AI as part of our students' future, so they're taking an "allow it, but regulate it" approach and Google's change doesn't impact us. I have mixed feelings about how tech is integrated in grade schools in general, but this _is_ something of an added burden to workaround for under-resourced districts who don't want it.
The instant someone offered me $1 more an hour I quit.
Its not like there aren't other options. It seems unreasonable that a user who (presumably) isn't paying should be able to dictate product decisions. If you dont like google's decisions, vote with your feet.
i know i know, I’m being deliberately obtuse, but I just hate this notion that people are just employees and they throw their hands in the air or shift blame to management.
if you are an employee you are responsible to the eyes of the people
Plus I don't get the point of petitioning a business to do something, it ain't a charity.
2. Google absolutely behaving nominally charitably around schools. The strategy around things like Chromebooks may have a well troded ulterior motive but that isn't on the books.
They have one. The way that it was structured and the issues that it takes up make it a minority union and so doesn't have any bargaining power.
As such, it cannot be a union registered with the NRLB and so will never have the bargaining power.
If it was instead a single group (e.g. subcontractors working for Google Fiber) then it would be easier to get the 50% vote and would have a single focus and could be a union that has collective bargaining power.
Google's revenue doesn't go to a union (except by way of an employee electing to pay those dues).
Dues are 1%. How is that non-neglibile?
When it's a charitable donation to fund labor lawyers and organizers for employees of Accenture and Cognizant, its a no for me.
There are only so many slices of a pie
I think the key difference for countries outside the US is they have stronger national cohesion and stronger national identity. The US is a country of immigrants (always has been, always will be, literally) and so it's harder to feel solidarity.
The exploited underclass don’t see themselves as the exploited underclass, and so they have no desire to band together to improve their situation. They believe that they too will become rich if they continue to play the game they’ve been told to play.
Polite disagree, and I say this as an American. The country is less than 300 years old. That's nothing.
I don't feel the US has an "extremely" strong national identity. It has a strong one, to be sure, but it is quite fractured.
It’s a bit like saying that unions should only be using typewriters because that’s what they always used.
Otherwise you haven’t joined a union, you’ve joined a PAC pretending to be a union.
There is precedent for this in Germany, at least, though I don't know anything other than it exists.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany
If the executives make the wrong choice, it's already the workers who will make up for it with an involuntary pay cut or layoffs.
That is the bulk of what union workers are doing every day through their unions.
That doesn't mean unions shouldn't try to intervene on issues of broader concern as well. It's not a zero-sum game.
Layoffs, forced "VEP"s, etc. are happening all over Google, but the union is more concerned about Gaza, Palestine, etc.
The friction here is that they don't want to bifurcate their main offers to maintain an "AI free" experience, because the thesis is this won't exist long term. I think this makes sense.
This is not opposed to telling employees not to "punish schools", whatever that means. Nobody is being punished, they're just not being catered to.
They're not the only company refusing to let people turn off AI features people don't want. In this case, it doesn't appear to matter what the customers want.
The claim that "customers don't want this" isn't backed up by data. What percent of customers don't want it? What percent of customers actually do want these features and use them all the time?
You're pretending there is no data when we're here responding to an article about how some customers don't want it.
Prove to us it's not a thing. Everyone would love to know this whole article is based on a false premise.
https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/products/gemini-app/on...
Google Search has 5 billion monthly users. I would be surprised if anti-AI users were even close to 50M, i.e. it's likely far less than 1% of the userbase. But if you want to make that argument, I would be interested to hear it.
Are we still arguing this in 2026? No they don't. Just shut them down.
I can further clarify, but I assume my point is clear.
There are so few competitors because Google has systematically starved them or bought them, so that it is practically impossible for anyone to compete with them on product or reach.
If they didn't want it to sound punitive, another solution might have been more appropriate. Google search today has a "Web" item (listed under "More" at the top of the page) which does provide search reasults without the AI overview. I think this indicates that this feature isn't so difficult to provide to schools, their paying customers.
A bet that everyone will only use AI. Which is wrong.
I’ll type a one word search term to find a site, the result I want will be at the top, and Gemini will pump out a completely irrelevant half-page summary about something completely unrelated to what I was looking for.
Well if that is the case, it would make schools’ decisions a lot easier if Google came out and said that.
Google is AI to the very core, to the very marrow of its bones, and it always has been. It wasn't always llm, but to pretend Google isn't AI is just ignoring the statue and staring at the fig leaf and thinking that's the product.
What you're saying is that we'll eat it and we'll like it.
We don't have to.
It's more like the bottom half of the jar is the same amount of peanut butter as ever and then they add a big squirt of mayo on top. They still make the old product as part of the bundle, and the bundle is the same price, but they insist on only having the bundle.