Why do tech leaders sound so illogical and off-putting?

(theatlantic.com)

28 points | by pseudolus 43 minutes ago

11 comments

  • mark_l_watson 6 minutes ago
    I think it is simply that some people are overwhelmed by some false illusion of their self importance. Love and kindness are the foundations of a happy and contented life, but people get caught up in their own life dramas and don’t think much of other people. I have worked at large stable companies (SAIC/Leidos), Google, Capital One, etc. and there is more of a sense of reality: people come to work to do a job. I have also worked at or helped many startups and usually it seems like it is some ego trip to save the world, or some other such nonsense.

    I don’t mean to be picking on anyone but there are tech leaders currently in the news that I don’t respect at all.

  • bloopernova 4 minutes ago
    I've wondered recently whether the Great Filter that prevents humanity from becoming a galactic species is not that space travel is hard. Instead, it's possible that we as a group are too easily misled by misinformation. That the lie can get around the world before the truth has time to lace up its shoes.

    Similarly, these executive class people live in a world soaked in misinformation. Their misinfo comes from their lack of pushback and criticism from others for various reasons, like being afraid of the power to fire anyone. Very much like a too-sycophantic LLM like the article suggests.

    Maybe if we had a few thousand years to let our brains adapt to not trusting anything, we might be OK.

  • Telemakhos 8 minutes ago
    The illogical, off-putting bits fade away when you assume tech leaders are lying to make money. AI doomerism from AI giants coupled with enthusiastic development of supposedly destructive technology makes sense if you assume the doomerism is a stance calculated to trigger regulation and regulatory capture that restricts AI to SaaS AI giants who want to be able to rent to you instead of letting you run open weight models.
  • pseudolus 42 minutes ago
  • xyzsparetimexyz 12 minutes ago
    It's an in-group signal like a shibboleth. Similar to buccal fat removal or 'bogging'. If you don't get it, you're not in the club.
    • cyanydeez 6 minutes ago
      I think this explains most of the detachment of modern society. Pre internet, mobile phone, etc, the billionaires had to have some level of interaction with the local rabble.

      Now, they can colude among themselves wherever which disconnects them from any potential scrutiny.

      We talk about social media bubbles while they're basically building the golden dome of reach around politics and beliefs.

  • varispeed 13 minutes ago
    If something is not clear, then it is always about money. Most people also are unable to follow logic, so these explanations don't sound illogical. They are just explanations about something most people don't understand anyway. What counts is appearance, how someone is dressed and whether they smile. A few keywords here and there and creation of feel good vibe. The information itself is irrelevant.
  • lijok 9 minutes ago
    Because you’re not the target audience. Effective communication is tailored to the audience. You wouldn’t inject yourself into the kitchen of a tasting restaurant and accuse the chefs of sounding unhinged.
    • soco 4 minutes ago
      I'm a bit bothered with comparing the techbros with fine cuisine. They are rather the mafia-owned pizza place. But you're right, one wouldn't get to accuse these either.
  • amelius 19 minutes ago
    Tech leaders are just a reflection of what VCs want to see.
    • dgellow 18 minutes ago
      There is a push/pull dynamic, it’s not a pure reflection
  • PaulHoule 26 minutes ago
    It’s been that way a long time, at least since the mid 2000’s. Part of Zuck’s origin story was getting brushed off by pharma-over-alles VCs in the Boston area and going to SV which was one of only two places that has a time when they’d fund social media sites. Or you could look at Mozilla that can’t find any ambitions than being a woke Chrome. At some point SV decided they were right about everything and won’t listen to anybody.
  • perching_aix 9 minutes ago
    > in Olympic-level mental gymnastics as they defended the former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s affairs: We must excuse his dalliances with two employees and an alleged Chinese spy, they argued, not just because Huang is absolutely necessary to the American economy, which is being propped up by AI investment, but because we are in a geopolitical superintelligence race with China.

    There is absolutely no mental gymnastics involved here, nor is this any illogical. Off-putting sure, but nothing about this is illogical. It's about as basic of a conundrum as it gets, and it was clear as day this was going to be a point of tension right from the get go. That's why it made such big news in the first place even.

    I really despise when people try to dress up their grievances and reframe them as matters of logic. The persistent group-identity profiling is hardly the mark of good faith reasoning either. Can't imagine the rest of this article being any more worthy of anyone's time.

  • freddealmeida 28 minutes ago
    I think the answer to that is most people are sub 105 IQ. They don't have the dimensional space to understand complex ideas especailly if built in time and through sacrifice. No salaried person can. At most it is an abstration, a simulacra of what it might be to lead a technology firm. We design a future we have no idea if people will accept it. Product market fit is actually more founder market fit.
    • codingdave 19 minutes ago
      That may be the most elitist thing I've read in a while. The differences between the smartest people and the average person are not as huge as all that. Average people are not incapable of complex thought. Smart people are not a different species. IQ tests are just a score, not a measure of capability.
    • f646993e074382f 3 minutes ago
      Thanks a lot for a great Friday afternoon laugh.
    • rf15 10 minutes ago
      You are obsessing over IQ as if its a serious metric...
    • kristopolous 15 minutes ago
      oh what's the brilliant ideas?

      A taxi service that uses your own car? Renting scooters and leaving them on sidewalks? An app for food delivery? Renting out an extra bedroom? Scrabble with friends? An app to share photos? Alright.

    • ozgrakkurt 12 minutes ago
      Saying tech CEOs have higher IQ than people they employ is a very bold statement.
      • Hugsbox 0 minutes ago
        It's like when people talk about what a genius Elon is for all of "his" accomplishments. His accomplishments being; sitting around doing ketamine while real engineers actually make shit happen.
    • brettermeier 14 minutes ago
      As if all those guys are super high intelligent... sometimes its just luck or inheritance.
    • combobyte 22 minutes ago
      "No salaried person can understand complex ideas"

      What a crock of shit.