Unblockable communication with gravity

(science.org)

134 points | by rbanffy 11 hours ago

15 comments

  • aetherspawn 1 hour ago
    It seems like they missed the opportunity to put the big heavy thing on a rotating disk and then encode the data as changes in velocity (frequency domain) which is way easier to do than an elevator, especially with a PM motor. This is basically FM vs AM.

    Intuitively if the thing is heavy enough it should have decent range, for example humans can “feel” an object of 100 tons spinning at decent distances one way or another. Not sure if this is a gravity phenomena or a vibrational one though. The rising/falling edges will be even more detectable than the mass itself, and intuitively increasing the energy level (speed) might increase the range? Wondering how far that scales, for example does it scale to 100,000 rpm - several megawatts? Can it be detected 1km away at that energy?

    • hnuser123456 21 minutes ago
      Humans would only feel vibration through the ground. On top of that, you can only directly "feel" gravitational waves by having a heavier, more stable point of reference. By its nature, you cannot feel your own acceleration due to gravity, unless there's macroscopic changes in the field across the size of your body, which requires being next to a black hole or neutron star.

      Some of the most precise clocks can detect elevation differences of 1cm or less based on varying speed of time at varying depths in the gravity well, but our biology cannot.

      Gravity is so weak, that if you were standing on an asteroid less than about 10 miles wide, you'd be able to jump to escape velocity with your legs.

  • arijun 21 minutes ago
    > Since mass cannot be negative, there is no gravitational analog of charge cancelation and hence no way to hide or screen the presence of mass.

    Is that truly the reason? It seems like negative charge would be neither necessary nor sufficient to have the equivalent of a Faraday cage.

  • marmakoide 9 hours ago
    Would it be easy to jam the signal ?

    Say, you have a big, heavy double pendulum moving close to the emitter. The moving mass would disturb the signal, and predicting the evolution of a double pendulum is not easy due to its instability (it's not periodic for example, so no Fourier analysis)

    • cvoss 8 hours ago
      > While this communication method cannot be passively blocked in the manner of EM shielding, it can, in principle, be affected by active signal degradation strategies. A malicious actor, Mallory, could attempt to jam the signal by moving other nearby masses or generating environmental vibrations, reducing the SNR at Bob’s gravimeter.
  • DavidSJ 4 hours ago
    The key idea seems to be:

    Since mass cannot be negative, there is no gravitational analog of charge cancelation and hence no way to hide or screen the presence of mass.

    Perhaps they address this in the paper, but it occurs to me that the obvious countermeasure is to shield with a large positive mass, and then to selectively remove some of this mass to cancel the attempted message.

    • tomxor 58 minutes ago
      > Perhaps they address this in the paper, but it occurs to me that the obvious countermeasure is to shield with a large positive mass, and then to selectively remove some of this mass to cancel the attempted message.

      It is, about 1/3rd down the page, they distinguish passive from active degradation:

      > While this communication method cannot be passively blocked in the manner of EM shielding, it can, in principle, be affected by active signal degradation strategies. A malicious actor, Mallory, could attempt to jam the signal by moving other nearby masses or generating environmental vibrations, reducing the SNR at Bob’s gravimeter. Mallory could also attempt to locally block (spoof) Alice’s signal by moving a nearby mass so as to counteract (reproduce) the change in gravitational field at Bob’s location. In this case, Bob would observe a modified or misleading signal rather than the one generated by Alice.

      > In a more elaborate scenario, Mallory could attempt to block the signal entirely by constructing the gravitational analog of a Faraday cage. This would require surrounding either Alice or Bob with a continuous distribution of controllable mass and dynamically reconfiguring it in response to Alice’s motion so as to cancel at all times. Such an arrangement, while not forbidden by physics, would require Mallory to have extraordinary capabilities with regard to control and coordination of mass distributions. We explore this possibility further in the Supplementary Materials.

    • markhahn 3 hours ago
      and the quoted statement doesn't actually follow, since there is a gravitational analog of cancellation: movement of mass on the opposite side of the receiving gravimeter. the opponent needs to know the receiver's location, but you can use a "phased array" of counter-emitters to zero the signal. or make it anything you want.
      • danielheath 1 hour ago
        > The opponent needs to know the receiver's location

        The opponent also needs to know what signal is going to be transmitted, right?

        Otherwise, the most they can do is introduce a 50% noise rate to the channel, which is sufficient to slow down communications considerably, but not sufficient to block them.

    • runako 3 hours ago
      > selectively remove some of this mass

      (Not a physicist) how would this work? If you remove mass, wouldn't that involve converting to energy? And doesn't energy have gravity too?

      • kennywinker 2 hours ago
        I read it as remove from that location. I.e. move it somewhere else.
    • MomsAVoxell 2 hours ago
      A waterfall attack, then.
    • superxpro12 4 hours ago
      that sounds.... heavy.

      chaff is the weight of a few pieces of cut up aluminum foil.

  • aftbit 14 minutes ago
    Three Body Problem anyone?
  • goda90 9 hours ago
    With an array of gravimeters, you could probably build an unblockable position tracker too.
  • markhahn 3 hours ago
    If I know where the "receving" gavimeter is, I can make it read anything I want, assuming I can place devices nearby.
    • asdfman123 3 hours ago
      How is that different than radio communication?

      We have encryption technology to keep things secure.

  • dmitrygr 31 minutes ago
    > The implementation is therefore straightforward, requiring only a mass and an off-the-shelf, hand-held gravimeter.

    > change in gravitational acceleration at Bob’s location is ∼5 nm/s^2

    Did I sleep through a renaissance in affordable gravimeters, wherein ones capable of such a fine measurement are now considered "off the shelf"? cool if so!

  • yodon 9 hours ago
    That's a very long article for something any 1st year experimental physics grad student could have just said "yes, of course you can detect the mass moved", followed, hopefully, by "but you've need an unbelievably weird threat model for it to actually be a good solution to whatever problem you think you're facing."

    To make the article more interesting, I'd extend it to both gravity waves and gravitational waves.

    • Ancalagon 5 hours ago
      they address that gravitational waves are too difficult to produce (requiring the mass of a stellar object) and too expensive to detect
      • rcxdude 2 hours ago
        This is practical in comparison to that, yes. But still extremely impractical. It's essentially a party trick (which is a whole genre of academic papers).
        • dmd 2 hours ago
          Mordechai Guri has made a career out of "party trick" data-exfiltration security papers - using speakers as microphones, encoding data in fan noise, encoding data in noise generated by writing pixels to the screen, turning power supplies into speakers by varying load, using ultrasound to affect nearby phones' MEMS gyroscopes, altering cpu activity patterns to produce FM radio... the list goes on and on.
    • marmakoide 8 hours ago
      That's a nice hobby project, it's always interesting to take something known to work in theory, and engineer it to the real world. Then, scaling it : longer transmissions distance, better bandwidth, etc. Exploration !
    • jerf 4 hours ago
      The ability to communicate via gravity has never been in question, it has always been a question of bitrate and expense. Note a single fiber optic cable in that lab running between the two rooms could achieve approximately 13.5 orders of magnitude higher bandwidth. 13.5 orders of magnitude is a lot for a threat model to overcome.

      Since some people can only seem to think about "advanced technologies" in terms of science fiction stories, a while back I decided to write a science fiction story explaining why gravitational communications are just silly, which may help such people: https://jerf.org/iri/post/2023/alien_communication/

    • a012 9 hours ago
      > whatever problem you think you're facing.

      We need advanced techs before Trisolarans arrive

      • jonapro 7 hours ago
        Cue “your mama” jokes…
  • pcj-github 1 hour ago
    "Should the reader ever experience prolonged entrapment in a soundproofed, Faraday-caged elevator with a malfunctioning phone, the present method offers an experimentally verified means of signaling for aid."
  • canadiantim 9 hours ago
    Wow, that's got some pretty heavy consequences. I feel very pulled towards this method of communication.
    • silon42 9 hours ago
      I place heavy mass behind you.
  • amelius 7 hours ago
    Aviation needs something like this for GPS.
    • davedx 6 hours ago
      • aftbit 11 minutes ago
        There are also these, which work on some spooky quantum principles.

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_laser_gyroscope

      • rdtsc 3 hours ago
        The only novel thing here is using these for terrestrial tactical navigation and tying them to wheel movements. ICBMs have been using these for decades. It’s incredible cool how they work.
      • amelius 4 hours ago
        Is it me or is the way they report error strange? It's in percentage of traveled distance.
        • ImPostingOnHN 20 minutes ago
          It seems to have active error correction which improves accuracy with more measurements/time.
    • someguydave 6 hours ago
      that's basically what an inertial reference system is
    • toomuchtodo 4 hours ago
      Astronav is underrated for this use case, in my humble opinion, especially as an INS auxiliary input when GNSS is being actively denied.
  • sgsjchs 9 hours ago
    > 1 bit per minute

    Lmao.

    Anyway, it's blockable by flooding the environment with noise, just like with EM. It's not like anyone blocks EM comms with shielding either.

    • gumby 7 hours ago
      One bit per minute (or as I'd prefer to call it, 1/60 Hz) is acceptable for some applications. Consider how submarine radio communication works for the doomsday weapons.
      • matthewmcg 6 hours ago
        Came here to see if anyone else had made the connection to submarine ELF.
    • tclancy 7 hours ago
      The paper discusses this directly and has a supplement to discuss what wicked old Mallory would need to do to block the signal entirely.

      > Such an arrangement, while not forbidden by physics, would require Mallory to have extraordinary capabilities with regard to control and coordination of mass distributions. We explore this possibility further in the Supplementary Materials.

      • BalistaCRATZ 5 hours ago
        This is true in response to creating a full faraday cage which completely cancels out the system. But if Mallory creates enough noise as to degrade the SNR sufficiently, it could still be practically blocked for any reasonably implemented receiver.
    • voidUpdate 9 hours ago
      Dont people block EM comms with faraday cages all the time?
      • HWR_14 9 hours ago
        Yes. Sometimes, but not always, intentionally.
      • Joel_Mckay 8 hours ago
        Not all shielding is created equally.

        People don't often see Silver coated Mu-metal in consumer equipment these days.

        If you know... you know why. =3

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mu-metal

        • atroon 7 hours ago
          >If you know... you know why. =3

          I don't know, and also don't know why. I'd love to learn why though.

          • aftbit 12 minutes ago
            I'm not entirely sure what the author is referring to, and radioactive contamination doesn't quite explain the problem to me. After all, most of the 1950s fallout has decayed away, and low background steel has been a thing for a long time.

            I was imagining something to do with booster bags and blocking magnetostrictive anti-theft tags.

          • Joel_Mckay 6 hours ago
            Metrology is a deep rabbit-hole, and trace radioactive isotope contamination of metal alloys was non-reversible on a global scale.

            Similarly, there are distinct elevated isotope traces in the biological lens in most modern peoples eyes if born after the 1950's.

            Have a wonderful day =3

            https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWFF7ecArBk