It'seasier to criticize anything for its shortcomings, rather than recognizing what it does better:
This is a phone that respects the user - not Samsung, Apple, Google, etc.
Reading all of the negativity, it sounds like people are implying we should never try because the first or second attempt will never have secondary features as goof as the mass market phones.
Remember: the primary feature is a phone that you truely own and can trust - you can't do that with the others.
IMHO, I think going with RISC-V is a mistake. It works if you only use PureOS/Mobian/Mura packages, but things like e.g. Signal or Flatpaks are only compiled with X86_64 in mind, so you are already limiting the scope of some apps on there (they mention this in the campaign about ARM64 emulation, but I'd need to be convinced).
There's been a bit of discussion on how performant the RISC-V processor is:
"in case I don't manage to blog about this device later in the week. Now, vector extensions are likely not used, affecting K1 benchmark results negatively, but still: Even if all #MobileLinux remain as lean as they are, the web will surely not, and shipping what seems to be the same real world performance in April 2028 as in a device envisioned ten years earlier and shipped about five years ago is... something (the RAM will definitely help though). One last pun for tonight: Also, when I read freedom, I immediately think of PowerVR graphics."
They are also reusing the Chassis from the Librem 5 v1, which means that if 5G is added, it probably will be sub-optimal.
As someone who backed the Librem 5 and runs mainline Linux as a daily driver since 2021, I'd say I'm very on the fence about this. If I knew that my money was also going to greater community development, I would be much more tempted to get this.
I've had my L5 for 3.5 years and I still think it's the coolest piece of tech that I own.
This looks like an improvement in every category for the hardware. That's all I really wanted. It will be interesting to see how software support shakes out for the new CPU architecture. 99% of what I use is in the main repos, so that's all I need.
I just want something to run Nura on (rebranding of PostmarketOS) that actually supports US market cellphone LTE bands, and is faster than the Pinephone Pro.
Wild they want to push out a RiscV variant this early on.
A mobile device which can't do realtime notifications from XMPP just won't work for me anymore. The Pinephone's "crust" mode was the only way the device wouldn't cook off the battery in less than half a day. But it disabled the CPU and Wifi, waking only for events from telephony (SMS and calls, specifically).
I'd be very surprised if this RISC-V phone didn't need something like crust.
I love this kind of stuff, but it's hardly practical as an actual phone you have to use for serious stuff like banking, proprietary 2FA apps, et cetera. The price being as expensive as it is isn't helping either...
I daily drive an L5. Guess I have to consider myself lucky not to be tethered to proprietary 2FA apps.
Except for banking. In Germany though, it fortunately still works just ok with a chip card reader. Not all banks support it though, and it feels like it's dwindling.
If someone were to pay attention to the 23/24 1099s, they'd find that Todd used company funds, that is your hard earned crowdfunded money, for something he really shouldn't have.
Disclaimer: I am priced out of being the audience for this phone.
Google and Apple have a monopoly on RCS messaging, and until additional providers can offer interoperability other phone OS’s will only appeal to the small population of people this phone is made for.
Well it's more performant than a NXP 8M Quad core Cortex A53, which was in their last phone. I don't think they make any attempt at being the fastest phone, it's more of a developer tool under the guise of a well polished device.
Small batch production of niche hardware will never match the prices brought to you by economies of scale. But that was never expected by anyone sane. This is yet another test of "there is demand for an open phone, I just FEEL it". We shall see how it plays out, but i wish them luck. I suspect they will need it.
The proposed chip is already 2 years out of date and lacks many security features that are common place and expected for modern devices. And don't forget how poorly the first campaign for the Librem 5 went where they went radio silent for years and refused to process refunds.
To put that into perspective, you can buy a $1000+ iPhone with seven years of software support.
Or you can buy a $1600 L5 v2 with "it's going to be mainlined" years of support. On that scale, it's actually affordable. Not a bargain, but affordable.
I think the average HN user understands this has nothing to do with competing with the iPhone or even Android phones. A real uh... apples to oranges comparison.
Do we really have to dismiss anything we disagree with as "AI"? There is zero evidence or suggestion that this was written by AI, and even if it was, the viewpoint it expresses is clearly human (and presumably quite widely shared).
Who do you think that this phone is for, if not for a subset of existing iOS or android users who care about foss products (for whom this must then compete with those options)?
Only because we don't have many choices to choose from. This phone expands that pool to choose from. The next project/company will then be trying to aim for a subset of existing iOS, Andoriod, and Librem 5 users.
Obviously it would be for those that care more about "foss" than other features and are willing to make this sacrifice. That this phone will have radically less mature software in comparison is a given.
This is a phone that respects the user - not Samsung, Apple, Google, etc.
Reading all of the negativity, it sounds like people are implying we should never try because the first or second attempt will never have secondary features as goof as the mass market phones.
Remember: the primary feature is a phone that you truely own and can trust - you can't do that with the others.
https://motorolaimgrepo.vtexassets.com/arquivos/Motorola_Thi...
IMHO, I think going with RISC-V is a mistake. It works if you only use PureOS/Mobian/Mura packages, but things like e.g. Signal or Flatpaks are only compiled with X86_64 in mind, so you are already limiting the scope of some apps on there (they mention this in the campaign about ARM64 emulation, but I'd need to be convinced).
There's been a bit of discussion on how performant the RISC-V processor is:
https://floss.social/@okias/117616860986317655
https://browser.geekbench.com/v6/cpu/compare/19472801?baseli...
and from: https://linmob.net/weekly-update-46-2026/
"in case I don't manage to blog about this device later in the week. Now, vector extensions are likely not used, affecting K1 benchmark results negatively, but still: Even if all #MobileLinux remain as lean as they are, the web will surely not, and shipping what seems to be the same real world performance in April 2028 as in a device envisioned ten years earlier and shipped about five years ago is... something (the RAM will definitely help though). One last pun for tonight: Also, when I read freedom, I immediately think of PowerVR graphics."
They are also reusing the Chassis from the Librem 5 v1, which means that if 5G is added, it probably will be sub-optimal.
As someone who backed the Librem 5 and runs mainline Linux as a daily driver since 2021, I'd say I'm very on the fence about this. If I knew that my money was also going to greater community development, I would be much more tempted to get this.
This looks like an improvement in every category for the hardware. That's all I really wanted. It will be interesting to see how software support shakes out for the new CPU architecture. 99% of what I use is in the main repos, so that's all I need.
Wild they want to push out a RiscV variant this early on.
I'd be very surprised if this RISC-V phone didn't need something like crust.
Except for banking. In Germany though, it fortunately still works just ok with a chip card reader. Not all banks support it though, and it feels like it's dwindling.
Google and Apple have a monopoly on RCS messaging, and until additional providers can offer interoperability other phone OS’s will only appeal to the small population of people this phone is made for.
Sounds like something the EU should take a closer look at.
Oh wait, it shouldn't, because then prominent US bloggers will keep on raging about EU "overregulation" for months.
The scary US bloggers. That's the problem with the EU
https://forums.puri.sm/t/librem-5-v2-a-risc-v-phone/31563 says they're using a SpacemiT K1, which is around the same ballpark performance as the little cores on a $20 Walmart Android phone from a decade ago.
Phoronix announcement has much less bullshit and actual useful details
https://www.phoronix.com/news/Librem-5-v2-Announced
For $1,599 you can have Motorola Signature 27, specs (and security) are better by orders of magnitude and the phone will also support GrapheneOS.
Or you can buy a $1600 L5 v2 with "it's going to be mainlined" years of support. On that scale, it's actually affordable. Not a bargain, but affordable.
The price of the Purism phone is $1599.
You might as well get the iPhone 17 Pro Max with that amount and save $$$ since it has millions of more apps and games on there.
This Purism phone is quite underdeveloped compared to the iPhone.
[0] https://puri.sm/librem-5-v2-crowdfunding-campaign/
I think the average HN user understands this has nothing to do with competing with the iPhone or even Android phones. A real uh... apples to oranges comparison.
Better just to respond to the argument, I say.
Only because we don't have many choices to choose from. This phone expands that pool to choose from. The next project/company will then be trying to aim for a subset of existing iOS, Andoriod, and Librem 5 users.