Just to say if you're interested in this kind of tech and are in the Bay Area, Sync Conf [0] just announced [1] its initial speaker lineup today and Arushi Bandi from Figma is one of the speakers.
This is still a hard problem today. Some hard tech was built for this. I'm excited for a world where this is more accessible and less hardcore than something like CRDTs (in terms of accessibility).
How have others noticed the world shifting in the past 6 years?
There are now a few sync engines that tackle this problem. Rocicorp Zero, Electric SQL, and one or two others. By no means a crowded space, but there are options now.
I know Liveblocks.io has been making this very easy and accessible over the last few years. They recently introduced AI, and are promoting that of course, but as I understand it multiplayer collaboration (https://liveblocks.io/multiplayer-editing) is their meat and potatoes.
Not affiliated with Liveblocks, just aware of its existence.
PubSub and LiveView do go a long way. However, broadcast isn't sync and LiveView isn't appropriate for all applications.
Phoenix recently added Phoenix.Sync [0], a sync engine library explicitly designed [1] to address this. In combination with a front-end library like TanStack DB [2] it goes much further towards giving you a Figma/Linear-style sync engine out of the box [3].
All the fundamentals have existed for at least 26 years. So, no, not really.
It's also really weird to use video game terminology and ignore the fact that all of the approaches used in this article have in fact, been done by major game engines, are readily documented in game development circles, etc.
It reads like an undergrad discovering game development for the first time. None of this is novel. It wasn't even novel for a web or desktop application to use.
Can you say more about which prior art you think overlaps here? We have a similar use case to Figma and are implementing a similar solution. I'm not particularly concerned whether the path we're following is novel but I am particularly concerned with whether there are gotchas along it that we should be watching out for, so if there are more mature solutions, we'd be interested.
My guess is they implemented dark mode, then discovered some legacy posts have videos with transparent backgrounds. As a quick fix, they decided to disable dark mode anytime someone scrolls down to a video.
Seems like one of those compromises to solve an 11th-hour bug.
The contents of this article are pretty old, but the static website's design has been revamped (I believe several times) since then. My guess it that the two may have just fallen out of sync in such a way that this particular oddity manifests.
Figma was born out of founder’s need to find a proof of concept test case for real-time collaboration JavaScript engine they created. They stumbled on this idea. Back then everyone used Sketch and wanted better prototyping and interaction design, and Figma appeared with its real time collaboration as major point which you used once just to try and never again.
Figma is one of the worst evils of corporate capitalism. The design oriented development is long ceases, mainly focusing on making new useless products because they need growth for shareholders. Considered a leader in UIUX design software while its own UIUX is abysmal, full of amateur level mistakes, inconsistencies and bad patterns.
We have now a generation of designers that take Figma’s UX as an example to learn from and implement in their designs.
> Figma was born out of founder’s need to find a proof of concept test case for real-time collaboration JavaScript engine they created. They stumbled on this idea.
citation needed?
The article discusses adding collaboration to an existing application, the opposite of what this comment asserts.
Evan Wallace basically said screw it, I'm writing a custom WebGL renderer and multiplayer protocol, when everyone else was slapping together existing libraries. Most of us would have built a janky Electron app and called it a day. Instead they went nuclear on performance because that WAS their product differentiation.
Curious why you copy/paste your previous comments verbatim[1]. I was reading it and could have sworn I have read that exact comment before and was thinking it's dejavu.
Not sure, their comment history doesn't look like it. If I had to guess, they got a fair amount of karma from the old comment and thought they could get away with reusing it and harvesting some more.
1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxK11RsLqp4&t=2169s
2. https://linear.app/now/scaling-the-linear-sync-engine
Also see this overview of related tech here:
3. https://gist.github.com/pesterhazy/3e039677f2e314cb77ffe3497...
And c.f. automerge from ink & switch:
4.https://automerge.org/blog/
[0]: https://syncconf.dev [1]: https://x.com/sync_conf/status/1957818840777122293
How have others noticed the world shifting in the past 6 years?
edit: links
Not affiliated with Liveblocks, just aware of its existence.
Innovators like him, are very rare.
Phoenix recently added Phoenix.Sync [0], a sync engine library explicitly designed [1] to address this. In combination with a front-end library like TanStack DB [2] it goes much further towards giving you a Figma/Linear-style sync engine out of the box [3].
[0] https://hexdocs.pm/phoenix_sync [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4IWShnVuRCg [2] https://electric-sql.com/blog/2025/07/29/local-first-sync-wi... [3] https://electric-sql.com/demos/burn
Disclaimer: Electric founder. Linking to my own talk / post / demo.
It's also really weird to use video game terminology and ignore the fact that all of the approaches used in this article have in fact, been done by major game engines, are readily documented in game development circles, etc.
It reads like an undergrad discovering game development for the first time. None of this is novel. It wasn't even novel for a web or desktop application to use.
How Figma's Multiplayer Technology Works - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21378858 - Oct 2019 (63 comments)
Also websockets are complicated. So are WebRTC or HTTP/2+ solutions.
HTTP/1.1 Comet-Stream is still the silver bullet even when ISPs try to block them, it's the protocol that goes through best (99.6% in 2022)
I'm considering doing a multi-socket solution: 80 (HTTP Comet-Stream) and 3724 (Binary TCP because WoW).
https://multiplayeronlinestandard.com
My guess is they implemented dark mode, then discovered some legacy posts have videos with transparent backgrounds. As a quick fix, they decided to disable dark mode anytime someone scrolls down to a video.
Seems like one of those compromises to solve an 11th-hour bug.
Figma is one of the worst evils of corporate capitalism. The design oriented development is long ceases, mainly focusing on making new useless products because they need growth for shareholders. Considered a leader in UIUX design software while its own UIUX is abysmal, full of amateur level mistakes, inconsistencies and bad patterns. We have now a generation of designers that take Figma’s UX as an example to learn from and implement in their designs.
citation needed?
The article discusses adding collaboration to an existing application, the opposite of what this comment asserts.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44438131