Fascism and Monopoly (2020)

(law.umich.edu)

46 points | by doener 4 hours ago

4 comments

  • EmX_3000 4 minutes ago
    Even academics don't know what fascism is in 2026. It's not orange, or toothbrush, mustache man bad. It's the merger of the state and the corporations. The only real difference between fascism and communism is that under fascism, you can own the means to production, as long as it serves the state.

    I have an Oxford English Dictionary, in print thankfully. Over the past few years they've changed the meaning of many words you thought you knew.

  • delichon 43 minutes ago
    This makes the point that more centralized corporate power makes that power easier to capture and abuse, without mentioning that the same applies to the most dominant and privileged corporate power, the state. If you see them as fundamentally different things it can make sense for the state to decentralize corporations. If you see them as variations on a theme, that approach just further entrenches the dominant corporate power.

    Yes, fewer, larger corporations made it easier for Hitler to seize control, but so did a more powerful, more centralized state.

    • dweinus 10 minutes ago
      It's an interesting point, but your conclusion rests on the idea that corporate powers act as direct competition or a check on state powers. They are not the former. To the extent that they are the latter, they do so for private gain, unrepresentative of the public good. I think the better conclusion to this point is that decentralization and direct accountability to the public should be expanded for both corporations and the state.
    • mindslight 19 minutes ago
      > the same applies to the most dominant and privileged corporate power, the state ... If you see them as fundamentally different things it can make sense for the state to decentralize corporations

      I'm coming from the same place as you - I view them both as instances of concentrated power, and I think pointing to abuses by one to absolve the other is fallacious sophistry.

      But I think you're drawing the completely wrong conclusion here. Giving the state a mandate to keep corpos small and limit their power does not inherently increase the state's power by what the corpos might have had - the same way that giving the state a mandate to restrict itself and not infringe upon our natural rights (eg the Bill of Rights) does not inherently give it more power to infringe upon them.

      Rather, politically speaking [0], constraints on all of these centralized power structures necessarily flow from The People onto a singular government (which logically cannot dodge popular accountability, whether it's by the ballot box or the ammo box), which then flow onto corpos (which would otherwise claim to be individually exempt from the will of the People). And ladening centralized power structures [1] with restrictions on how much power they might accrue is how we preserve individual liberty.

      [0] as opposed to physical constraints - like the economies of scale of manufacturing, or the individual liberty of cryptographic privacy

      [1] especially ones whose sine qua non is state legibility!

    • kolbe 14 minutes ago
      I find it interesting how "concentration of power" has become a pejorative that no one questions. Depending on the context, a concentration of power is far better than the democratization of it. I don't want some illiterate meth addict having any power over the direction of GPU development. There's a good reason we have these silos of expertise called corporations, that allow an appropriate amount of concentration of power being given to the people best equipped to handle that power.
    • walt_grata 39 minutes ago
      Can you show me where the general citizens have the same degree of oversight and can impact the board or c suite that they have over elected officials? If you can demonstrate that I'll hop on that they're the same.
      • brightball 26 minutes ago
        Yes. It’s called voting with your wallet.

        When you disapprove of a corporation, you stop spending money with them and go to a competitor.

        You have no such choice with government. Regulations tend to be marketed with good intentions while simply raising the cost for competitors to enter the market, further reducing your options and entrenching the existing companies.

        • _petronius 15 minutes ago
          Governments collapse all the time because legitimacy is withdrawn by the electorate (from recent history alone: Arab Spring in various countries 2010-2012, Ukraine 2013/14, Bangladesh 2024, South Korea 2025, Nepal 2025, Serbia 2026, etc. etc.).

          Corporations usually collapse only due to insolvency, and these are basically never driven by "voting with the wallet" -- the very concept is something of a fallacy, because it assumes the primary financial concern of a large global company is revenue from individual consumers, which is largely not true.

          Believing that electoral politics is ineffective but corporate are somehow accountable to regular consumers is to understand the political forces exactly backwards from what they are in reality.

        • HeatrayEnjoyer 9 minutes ago
          Votes should be proportioned by individual, not by wealth.
        • thayne 18 minutes ago
          With a monopoly or oligopoly, you don't have a choice of who you can "vote" for with your wallet. It's like a "democracy" with only one name on the ballet.
        • pepperoni_pizza 15 minutes ago
          The problem with voting with your wallet is that some people have few votes, and some have few billion votes.
        • karmakurtisaani 18 minutes ago
          So how do I influence a tobacco company when I don't smoke?

          If I disagree with a political party, I can always vote a party that does opposite policy.

        • Avicebron 20 minutes ago
          > Yes. It’s called voting with your wallet.

          And when your bank doesn't let you download their app because you aren't on a android or iphone? Voting with your wallet is a fun zinger, but in practice it's not really a solution. That's why people have said for decades (centuries?) that laissez-faire capitalism is bad.

      • delichon 35 minutes ago
        Personally I feel entirely powerless to exercise oversight on either. I believe that no vote I have every made has made any difference. From down here they do look very much alike.
        • viklove 34 minutes ago
          The problem is your perception, not democracy.
          • wpietri 6 minutes ago
            Agreed. The US has just gone though an election that served as a major rebuke to the party in power. It's such a dramatic swing that the world's richest man suddenly changed his tune.

            Or we could look at Hungary, which in April booted out a 16-year authoritarian regime again due to elections. And there are plenty of other examples.

            I get that many people don't feel individually powerful under democracy. But that's pretty close to the point of democracy.

          • lioeters 32 minutes ago
            The problem is reality and facts, not the illusion of choice.
            • HeatrayEnjoyer 11 minutes ago
              The 2026 midterm election results are not an illusion.

              Defeatism isn't a plan, but sometimes is a subversive weapon.

      • inshard 37 minutes ago
        Public shares.
        • Avicebron 36 minutes ago
          What percentage of a company should a government own to force them to act them in the best interest of the people?
        • pasquinelli 34 minutes ago
          people own shares to make money, they are citizens out of a need to live.
          • BobBagwill 26 minutes ago
            I invested all my retirement savings in Soylent Green. They even sent me a free invitation to the Thanatorium as a thank you!
  • somat 24 minutes ago
    It is sort of interesting how fascism and communism despite appearing to be on the opposite ends of the political spectrum end up in the same place. Fascism, as an economic policy, says the people making the economy(the corporation) should run the government. Communism says the people should run the economy, which as a practical measure basically means the government(the will of the people right, stop laughing) runs the corporations. But in both cases it ends up being a grand unified government run economy, surely nothing could go wrong with that, right?

    Come for next weeks rant where I try and convince you that corporations are governments. hint it is all just groups of people and the rules that govern them.

    And final thoughts: It is impossible(probably for a good reason) to discuss fascism as an economic theory without carrying along the tremendous sins of them who employed it. It is easier to talk about communism as a theory, but them that employed it have committed sins as bad if not worse. And capitalism gets free reign for some reason.

    • exogeny 21 minutes ago
      Said another way, political alignment isn't a continuum, it's a horseshoe. The far left has more in common with the far right than they do anyone in the center.
    • christkv 10 minutes ago
      They are similar in a lot of ways but different in implementation. Fascism co-opts the private sector but does not destroy it. Unless it resists the design of the state the private sector is left more or less intact as well as the institutions of the state. Communism destroys both the private sector and the public institutions in the name of ideology. Companies are nationalised more aggressively and the managerial and capital class is the public enemy. Institutions are hollowed out. You can see this in the difference in the speed of recovery of nations after communism and fascism. Germany, Spain, Portugal, Italy all recovered quickly after the end of fascism as the pillars of the national was still there.

      I would hardly call fascism an economic theory. The approach was different from each country. For example Spain ran a plan economy after the civil war until the regime was convinced that liberalisation was the way to get out of the economic disaster the country was in.

    • throw9398922 6 minutes ago
      They were all socialist parties, with super heavy state involvement. It is not like Mussolini supported libertarian policies, or minimising role of government...