Derek Lowe: Detonating a Pile of Lead Azide

(science.org)

125 points | by beginning_end 1 hour ago

21 comments

  • cogman10 38 minutes ago
    What a mess. But this is exactly what's wrong with the US military.

    This factory was built by the US government for WW2. It was operated by the government until the 60s where it was ultimately shut down. In 1998 it was later converted to a contractor operated facility and has been ever since.

    We gave those companies so much money and they decided it was fine cutting corners and improperly handling the explosive ordinances under their care. We've literally given this company 4+ billion dollars, most of that in recent years with this year's spend being 270M https://www.usaspending.gov/recipient/1286c0e7-b6b5-8c72-290...

    And for all that money dumped on them, what we've ended up with is the US government taking ownership of them mishandling large amounts of dangerous chemicals.

    When someone talks about "waste, fraud, and abuse" This is it. This is what the $1.5T military budget is buying. Huge investments into an army of negligent private companies. No doubt they lobby well.

    • euroderf 4 minutes ago
      What do you want to bet their aggregate political contributions would have sufficed to handle the stockpile properly.
  • ChrisMarshallNY 1 hour ago
    I have been reading about this, and not quite understanding.

    Derek Lowe is a master explainer, and I now understand.

    • manwithaplan 54 minutes ago
      [flagged]
      • DonaldPShimoda 52 minutes ago
        You can't be serious. Typos have nothing to do with whether something is explained well. In both the cited cases, the intent of the sentence is obvious to anyone with even a passable understanding of the English language.
        • havnagiggle 43 minutes ago
          An editor would catch such things. But I guess that's just not valuable enough to the business, idk.
        • swed420 39 minutes ago
          Typos in this age can also be a human attempting to convince the reader they didn't post AI slop, or it can also be AI attempting to seem more human.

          (To me, the silent downvotes indicate some people want to hoard this little trick for themselves)

      • ChrisMarshallNY 21 minutes ago
        Feel free to ignore him.

        I feel my world is easier to understand, because I don’t.

        He’s also quite funny.

  • gpm 57 minutes ago
    > Covering it with more dirt and concrete and leaving it there is also not going to work. The chance of a accidental detonation is just going to get worse every year down there, and it’s hard to see how any work could get done around the whole facility under those conditions. Needless to say, “bury it and try to get on with your life” is not considered a reasonable regulatory solution, either.

    Why isn't the answer bury it then detonate it (using the concrete/soil/... to keep the lead contained) then dig out the site and capture all the lead.

    • wongarsu 41 minutes ago
      It's the equivalent of about 3000-4000 pounds of TNT, or 1.3-1.8 tons of TNT. And like TNT lead azide is a high explosive, so you get very intense shock waves

      I would expect piling as much concrete, soil and water around it as you can without disturbing it is useful, but containing it completely would be difficult

    • maxerickson 18 minutes ago
      It's basically already buried. I wonder how long it would take to double the mass of the cover, and how likely that would be to trigger a detonation (lots of vibration with heavy machinery).
    • fwip 45 minutes ago
      I also felt like that question wasn't answered.

      But I wouldn't want to be the person operating the heavy machinery required to bring in tons of dirt and concrete and to spread it around. I don't know for sure, but I imagine the vibrations involved wouldn't be good for safety - and even if it's fine, you still are working on top of a time bomb.

      • gpm 41 minutes ago
        I'd imagine you'd have to do it via remote control and be prepared for the eventuality that it goes boom early. That still seems worth it.
        • bluGill 27 minutes ago
          Time is the problem. If we do a controlled technician now, we know exactly when it happens and so we can ensure that the weather conditions are the best possible.

          If you try and encase this in something, the vibrations are going to happen over the months of building. If we could encase it within 10 minutes, no problem, we choose the day and either it goes from vibration; or it's encased and we're fine. The problem is, building a structure like this would take months, and at any time during construction, you risk that the wrong vibration happens the whole thing goes, possibly, on the worst possible day.

      • thehappypm 37 minutes ago
        How do you bury something in concrete that you can’t shock even a little bit?
    • admash 41 minutes ago
      Because unless you're planning on having ants bury it one sand grain at a time, the vibrations of the machinery used or even the settling of the material you are burying it under would likely be enough to detonate the lead azide crystals.
    • Brotkrumen 45 minutes ago
      The article says that it may go boom while you try to dump stuff on it. Uncontrolled boom at random weather seems to be bad.
      • dumbfounder 39 minutes ago
        Wait a few more years and get some drone dozers in there on good days. Maybe plant lots of trees and wait. Create a big pond over it. Seems like we didn’t put a lot of effort into this.
        • bluGill 26 minutes ago
          We may not have years. Nobody knows when this is gonna go, but something's gonna cause it to happen eventually as the crystals keep degrading.
        • xgulfie 38 minutes ago
          You can buy remote control heavy equipment today.
  • dofm 21 minutes ago
    This is the person I wanted to hear from on this subject!
  • reenorap 20 minutes ago
    The article mentioned not wanting rainfall during detonation, but isn’t that exactly what you want to contain any dust from traveling too far and contaminating areas further away with lead?
    • bgilroy26 13 minutes ago
      I bet they weighed that benefit against the harm of the like runoff and water table stuff
    • busterarm 17 minutes ago
      Not if it's 2-4-5 Trioxin! :D

      Jokes aside though, rain will make sure whatever chemicals it's carrying with it makes it into your water supply via storm drains, streams, rivers, etc.

  • comrade1234 1 hour ago
    10,000 pounds of lead azide is 4500kg, so about 3200kg of lead being released in the explosion.
    • nbernard 6 minutes ago
      For comparison, when Notre-Dame burned in Paris, about 400 tonnes of lead (from the roof) were released...
    • daemonologist 21 minutes ago
      Or about 1% the annual lead emissions of private aviation in the US (leaded gas is still used in almost all piston aircraft which is, in my opinion, unconscionable). Much more concentrated, of course.
    • xattt 54 minutes ago
      About 320 car batteries or about half an American football field of lead rolled as thin as a sheet of paper.
      • xnx 19 minutes ago
        Thank you for the conversion to American units.
        • xattt 16 minutes ago
          Accessibility for all!
      • gpm 42 minutes ago
        Enough lead to make 90 cubic kilometres of air beyond OSHA's permissible exposure level.
        • dead_hn_theory 29 minutes ago
          The OSHA inspector called in sick that morning.
    • InsideOutSanta 26 minutes ago
      For comparison, the US still puts about 600 tons of lead into the air every year, mostly from airplanes.
    • lazide 42 minutes ago
      Notably, lead is very dense so that isn’t actually a lot of lead by volume.

      It has the volume of about 400 liters of water, or 100 gallons. In ingot form, less than a single pallet, or roughly 3 mostly full 55 gallon drums.

  • gregwebs 29 minutes ago
    I would like to see another option explored/explained: abandonment.

    As I understand it, one of the reasons for a larger plume is the fact that they are directing the explosion away from the community.

    So in addition to abandoning the munitions/military facilities this might also mean abandoning Middleton, IA, population 363. They would be weighing relocating with incentive against dealing with heavy metal contamination in their community.

    • tptacek 8 minutes ago
      It's going to blow up either way, so what problem does abandonment solve?
  • zug_zug 1 hour ago
    I mean it can be true that in the current situation we're in, detonating it is less unreasonable than leaving it.

    But at the same time, the fact that we are in this situation now is entirely unreasonable/unacceptable. You'd never see this happen around where wealthy people live.

    • selectodude 1 hour ago
      I think that’s more because wealthy people aren’t going to move in next to a munitions factory.
      • zug_zug 1 hour ago
        They build munitions factories and army bases in poor areas. And then these bases keep the property values low.

        You don't think they'd have thought about this problem 15 years ago if it was next to LA?

        • Legend2440 54 minutes ago
          They build it in rural areas because there's not as many people there. Rural areas happen to be poor.

          Putting a munitions depot in the middle of a dense city would be highly irresponsible.

          • bluGill 22 minutes ago
            Poor in rural areas is misconception. There are a lot of poor people in rural areas, however, farmers tend to be very rich. Farmers often seem poor because all their wealth is tied up in massive amount of land and millions of dollars worth of equipment. However, at any time they can liquidate all that equipment on land and they would have millions of dollars. Well, assuming all that's paid off, the bank likely owns a fair amount of it, but slowly that gets paid off
          • justincormack 32 minutes ago
            Like say Woolwich, site of the Woolwich Arsenal (that the football team is named after) https://www.royal-arsenal-history.com/magazine_explosions.ht...

            The main gunpowder factory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waltham_Abbey_Royal_Gunpowder_... was built outside London, although London grew after, its near the M25.

          • lazide 41 minutes ago
            And yet, incredibly entertaining.
        • sarchertech 17 minutes ago
          They haven’t built a new army base since WW2. But when they do build new military bases, they build them where they can get cheap land.

          Theres also plenty of military bases near Los Angeles.

        • cowsandmilk 51 minutes ago
          > thought about this problem

          As described in the article, the storage system for the lead azide was constructed with this possibility in mind

        • cma 32 minutes ago
          One of these was more than 15 years ago, but there have been similar problems next to LA:

          > On August 3 [2018], a steel canister filled with hot nuclear waste was being lowered twenty feet into underground storage at San Onofre when the canister was accidentally hung up on a quarter-inch piece of metal. The canister was stuck for forty-five minutes while workers tried to figure out what happened.

          https://www.nbcsandiego.com/news/local/serious-near-miss-acc...

          > On December 11, 2002, a Department of Energy (DOE) official, Mike Lopez, described typical clean-up procedures executed by Field Lab employees in the past. Workers would dispose of barrels filled with highly toxic waste by shooting the barrels with rifles so that they would explode and release their contents into the air. It is unclear when this process ended, but for certain did end prior to the 1990s.

          https://parentsagainstssfl.com/accidents

      • Loughla 1 hour ago
        I worked in the area that's now projected to be impacted by this on Monday (West Central Illinois).

        There's a lot of poor, small towns. Not really people with any sort of economic or political clout. I texted a guy I made friends with when I was there, and he says most people are just sort of resigned to whatever happens with this. Life is already pretty shitty for a lot of folks there, and cancer rates are pretty high, so what's a little lead in the soil and water?

        He laughed about the warnings you stay indoors. The warmer weather means more people are working outside than usual because construction and concrete work hasn't shut down for the year.

        What a mess.

        • hypercube33 49 minutes ago
          I'm in and from near the area (let's say I'm Midwest but I'm in Wisconsin, Iowa and Minnesota enough) that this is basically true. people are mad but also feel helpless to do anything so they carry on.

          Iowa also has a major nitrate pollution problem but everyday people really don't have a lot of power to change a lot alone.

          • dofm 7 minutes ago
            The caucuses for 2028 might be a little lively on environmental issues, I guess.
      • exe34 1 hour ago
        Will a munitions factory be allowed to be built where rich people live?
  • millspore 27 minutes ago
    does anyone know wht actually sets it off, the pile's survived storms for years already?
    • tptacek 7 minutes ago
      It was in a more stable form, and is getting less stable over time; it's a threshold-crossing issue.
  • jmyeet 1 hour ago
    Large organizations fascinate me from a systems POV because you end up with very weird things going wrong once something is neglected and the knowledge gets lost. In this case, there's speculation that it was probably somebody's job to stir this every now and again and test to see if it's stable. For reference, in liquid form it's OK (ish) but it's bad when it crystallizes. Those crystals will detonate if they impact each other. And that person either moved on, retired or was fired and the new guy didn't do it and that information was lost. It was probably some variant of that.

    Another kind of famous example of this is that in 2014 somebody found some vials of smallpox in cold storage with unclear origins [1].

    Part of the issue here is it's unclear what the impact of the plume contamination will be and where it will go. You can't give a notice days in advance of where the wind will blow. It doesn't work that way. But there also don't seem to be good alternatives.

    [1]: https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/biosecurity-issues/decades-old-sm...

    • dofm 0 minutes ago
      Wind direction is hard to predict with precision several days out, but wind likelihood less so.

      So I suppose what you want in this situation is just to know it won’t be windy, because that likely puts you in the domain of the prevailing wind for the purposes of planning; that is better known.

      One problem potentially with the weather is that not only might the cold weather itself increase the risk of unplanned detonation, the prevailing wind direction also might change as the weather cools, increasing the chance of it blowing in an unfavourable direction.

  • xgulfie 39 minutes ago
    One thing I haven't understood is why dont we telepoerate some robots to chemically mitigate it. Then even if doesn't work and it explodes you're in the same situation but just down a robot
    • bluGill 20 minutes ago
      To do anything useful would take months, even with robots. If we detonate, we can choose exactly the day it goes. If a robot is working and it detonates, we don't know which day it's going to go.
  • woadwarrior01 1 hour ago
    10,000 pounds of lead azide would roughly be ~7,100 pounds of elemental lead by molar mass. I guess Middletown, Iowa is going on the list of EPA Superfund sites.
    • maxerickson 49 minutes ago
      It wouldn't be crazy for a house that was built with leaded materials to have a couple hundred pounds of lead. That's not being released right into the environment of course, but provides some kind of check on the scale.

      Before it was banned, there was a couple of grams in each gallon of gas. That's a couple million gallons of gas to release the same amount of lead. We certainly did that over and over.

      I'm not saying it's a good idea to just blow it up without any further process, I'm wondering if it's really a particularly extreme release.

      • cogman10 35 minutes ago
        Leaded gas was burned across the nation and had noticeable health effects. This will be concentrated at a single point. That's the big problem. It might not have national effects, but it will certainly have lasting local effects.
        • lazide 34 minutes ago
          Just makes it easier to mine and recycle.
    • thehappypm 35 minutes ago
      That’s about a 2 foot cube of lead.
    • lazide 35 minutes ago
      That is about 1/20th a typical shooting range. They just mine those periodically, and recycle it.
  • Culonavirus 36 minutes ago
    Wait, I've seen The Return of the Living Dead... I know how this ends.
  • cachius 55 minutes ago
    Instead of lead to nowhere, it’s going to Iowa now :-(
  • cm2012 1 hour ago
    Such a fascinating explainer!
  • dead_hn_theory 1 hour ago
    Queues up Impressions of Sorcerer
  • secondcoming 1 hour ago
    IANA Chemist:

    Is it not possible to place a chemical (handwaving) on the containers to dissolve a small hole in them so that the contents get slowly dissolved/diluted?

    • cowsandmilk 56 minutes ago
      1. Drums are designed to be inert, so anything to eat through them will have to be a very strong chemical, most likely one you don’t want to come into contact with the lead azide.

      2. Eating through the surface of a drum will release heat. That heat could also cause the lead azide to ignite.

      • wongarsu 38 minutes ago
        Also they are stored submerged in a water/ethanol mixture, so you would need something that isn't diluted to uselessness by that. Which narrows your options substantially
      • gpm 50 minutes ago
        > 2. Eating through the surface of a drum will release heat. That heat could also cause the lead azide to ignite.

        Ok, and?

        If the plan is to detonate it... why not modify the plan to be "prepare for it to detonate then try and handle it (robotically) in a non-detonative fashion".

        • amcoy37 34 minutes ago
          They want to avoid an unplanned detonation that might occur when the wind is blowing toward town, or when it's raining, or when there's a temperature inversion -- it's in the (short) article.
        • fwip 37 minutes ago
          Well, the weather conditions matter, and they're evacuating the surrounding area for 4 hours.

          Doing experimental chemistry on 59 barrels with a robot seems to spread the explosion risk over several days. Also assumes you can source a mobile robot suited for doing chemistry in the next few days and train the operator up how to use it.

          • gpm 34 minutes ago
            They've known about this problem for months.

            Even now the only reason for "the next few days" seems to be their unwillingness to simply blow warm air at the barrels to keep them warm. An entirely artificial constraint.

    • throwup238 1 hour ago
      The problem is that it is already dissolved in the water/ethanol mixture, and now it’s recrystallizing out of the solution in a form that is less stable and easier to accidentally detonate.
  • senectus1 30 minutes ago
    making the next generation of MAGA ...
  • amelius 46 minutes ago
    Can we extract the energy from this event and store it somehow?

    Any useful work we can do with it?

    • stop50 28 minutes ago
      we could try ro top the record for the fastest manmade object, but that would mean to mean that we have to transport that stuff.
  • charv 54 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • aaron695 1 hour ago
    [dead]