The strategic commander always felt like it should have been more successful. On paper it is the perfect the missing half for the native PC FPS controller.
So, the mouse, If you had asked anyone to design a bespoke FPS controller, they would not design a mouse, yet somehow, this thing built to do something totally different, point at things on the screen, has proven to be the best fps controller, nobody has come up with anything better. Probably something about it's huge(for controller sizes) swing distance and absolute positioning.
The problem is the other half, the keyboard, on the one hand it is sort of nice to have 100+ buttons to use, but you almost never need that many and it stinks to only have binary(on/off) movement.
I have seen half controllers designed to solve this, but they never have enough buttons and are hard to hold, but the strategic commander, that makes one think, forget what it was built for, the RTS, it looks awkward as hell for that, but it does look perfect for the FPS.
Biomechanically and due to how the nervous system works, the fastest and most precise movements can only be done with full arm movement and fingers for extra accuracy, on a device which is the most reactive (e.g. zero weight/static friction/hysteresis/dead zones) and has a very specific movement resistance (e.g. dynamic friction), low enough but not too low. Many control schemes have been tried over decades but these basic rules seem to give the best results. Which only leaves the scheme most skilled FPS players already prefer: a basic, most lightweight mouse with a properly centered sensor, held with something close to a claw grip, without too many buttons that would mess up your aiming. Plus a keyboard under the other hand, it's a lot less important than the mouse.
Casual FPS play is more forgiving, e.g. gyro seems to work for many people as well (full arm + precise movement again, but not ideally reactive/resistant). But you can't put too many buttons on such a controller either.
So, the mouse, If you had asked anyone to design a bespoke FPS controller, they would not design a mouse, yet somehow, this thing built to do something totally different, point at things on the screen, has proven to be the best fps controller, nobody has come up with anything better. Probably something about it's huge(for controller sizes) swing distance and absolute positioning.
The problem is the other half, the keyboard, on the one hand it is sort of nice to have 100+ buttons to use, but you almost never need that many and it stinks to only have binary(on/off) movement.
I have seen half controllers designed to solve this, but they never have enough buttons and are hard to hold, but the strategic commander, that makes one think, forget what it was built for, the RTS, it looks awkward as hell for that, but it does look perfect for the FPS.
Casual FPS play is more forgiving, e.g. gyro seems to work for many people as well (full arm + precise movement again, but not ideally reactive/resistant). But you can't put too many buttons on such a controller either.
Such a cool peripheral even to this day, and completely magic around its release.