I don’t understand why we need id.me when login.gov exists, is less intrusive to sign up for, and is actually managed by the government. Why do we always need to insert a profit-seeking middleman in citizens’ dealings with the government?
I've been audited by the IRS almost every year since I was 18 years old. This privacy violation is incredibly horrible but it's not surprising to me. The IRS is a corrupt organization that supports the rich paying no taxes while harassing the common people for nickels and dimes.
you go from hiding from the IRS hoping you never get an inconvenient bill from them
to collaborating with the IRS with them signing off on how you’re not going to pay them
I’m personally motivated by this arrangement. The IRS is several different business units that don’t know how the other one moves. And the tax code by number (ie. Section 400 for tax deferrals like retirement plans vs Section 500 for tax exempt organizations) is an entirely different universe than the other number. Nobody gets a fully clear picture except you for the arrangement you’ve synthesized for yourself
Add a lawyer to the mix and its impossible for the government to know what your legal strategy was to disagree with it. The expense alone - of finding out or being wrong - is a deterrent, the energy is focused on cheaper defendants that took a tax credit for being poor
America really is a parody in many ways. Thought Soviet Russia had its hand in people's pockets? In United States, you have to pay Company for right to pay Government! (through 3rd party login vendors and through tax prep software lobbying to prevent simplification of your tax filing)
Your comment is being flippant with some pretty serious concerns.
Costs don't always present in dollars at the transaction time. There's downside risk to not being able to log into ID.me / IRS online systems.
(1) ID.me doesn't have a 100% accuracy rate. I remember lots of problems when states used them for welfare benefits.
(2) IIRC it raises the requirements for which devices you must use to login (this is old info, so it may no longer apply).
(3) Paper filing is not nearly as fast as online filing, so it could mean weeks of the government holding onto your money longer than needed.
(4) CPAs can charge a lot more than TurboTax / H&RBlock for the simplest filings. Being stuck with paper as the only option is a financial penalty.
(5) The parent mentioned Intuit lobbying to kill the US government's free IRS website filing. That's is even more work that the average OECD country where the government is responsible for doing your taxes for you, as opposed to the US where the time and cost is a burden on the citizen/worker.
Free for consumers means passed to consumers in an opaque way. There is zero reason for commerce to be involved in paying my taxes, or to be required to intermediate software access to services.
See https://sa.www4.irs.gov/ola
Elizabeth Warren did raise why they didn't use Login.gov instead:
- https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/10/29/congress/wy...
- https://www.finance.senate.gov/ranking-members-news/wyden-wa...
you go from hiding from the IRS hoping you never get an inconvenient bill from them
to collaborating with the IRS with them signing off on how you’re not going to pay them
I’m personally motivated by this arrangement. The IRS is several different business units that don’t know how the other one moves. And the tax code by number (ie. Section 400 for tax deferrals like retirement plans vs Section 500 for tax exempt organizations) is an entirely different universe than the other number. Nobody gets a fully clear picture except you for the arrangement you’ve synthesized for yourself
Add a lawyer to the mix and its impossible for the government to know what your legal strategy was to disagree with it. The expense alone - of finding out or being wrong - is a deterrent, the energy is focused on cheaper defendants that took a tax credit for being poor
But id.me is free for consumers and you strictly don't have to use tax filing software? It's a hassle, but not exactly required either.
Costs don't always present in dollars at the transaction time. There's downside risk to not being able to log into ID.me / IRS online systems.
(1) ID.me doesn't have a 100% accuracy rate. I remember lots of problems when states used them for welfare benefits.
(2) IIRC it raises the requirements for which devices you must use to login (this is old info, so it may no longer apply).
(3) Paper filing is not nearly as fast as online filing, so it could mean weeks of the government holding onto your money longer than needed.
(4) CPAs can charge a lot more than TurboTax / H&RBlock for the simplest filings. Being stuck with paper as the only option is a financial penalty.
(5) The parent mentioned Intuit lobbying to kill the US government's free IRS website filing. That's is even more work that the average OECD country where the government is responsible for doing your taxes for you, as opposed to the US where the time and cost is a burden on the citizen/worker.