Tell HN: HN is being scraped for emails to scam

I know that many folks here post their personal emails in the Who's for Hire monthly pages and other places, and want to remind you that this public site gets views from folks with ill intent (or their bots/agents) as well. I use unique emails for every site, so I immediately knew that the late AWS payments email sent to my HN email were fake. There were other tells, but I want to remind everyone to be vigilant! HN is public but even social media sites where you supposedly can make your page private I've had some of those emails suddenly have spam sent to as well. Please be safe everyone!

My favorite tells that an email is a scam: - Before opening a surprising/suspicious email, hover over the sender name to see the domain the sender came from (don't open the email if it's strange). - _If_ you already opened the email, before clicking any links in the email, hover over them to see the domain that the link sends you to.

There are dozens more tips but a full article would be required, and these two will prevent you from falling for nearly all of them.

117 points | by eks391 15 hours ago

25 comments

  • btrettel 14 hours ago
    There has been some previous discussion of this problem:

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50153608

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50142714

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50095323

    I switched to using a throwaway email address in an image in the "Who wants to be hired?" thread. The signal-to-noise ratio has increased greatly since then. I've received two spam emails and one legitimate email so far, which is a huge improvement.

  • koito17 13 hours ago
    One of my throwaway HN accounts from 7 years ago ended up giving me an e-mail with scary amount of context. I'm guessing the e-mail address appears in a separate database sold by a data broker, and they were able to use that to contextualize the e-mail.

    But they were sloppy enough to not pay attention to very basic details that made it obvious their location is a lie.

  • david_allison 12 hours ago
    I regret posting on the 'Who wants to be hired?' thread due to this.

    It's half burned my primary dev email

    • dang 11 hours ago
      Those posts remain permanently deletable, FWIW.
      • tasuki 9 hours ago
        Yes, but also it's too late. Unleaking is not a thing.
      • david_allison 9 hours ago
        Oh, thank you!
    • walrus01 11 hours ago
      On the other hand, this could be an interesting way to create a honeypot to collect fake-job-interview "install this" scripts that install some form of RAT or other malware, and then examine it.
      • zahlman 6 hours ago
        I'm pretty sure they don't generally send you the malware in the first contact.
        • walrus01 5 hours ago
          No, but they do seem to after just 1 or 2 back and forth sessions in email. Maybe a way to hand it off to some enthusiastic scambait or security research people for the reply part? Heck, you could probably set an LLM with the right prompt to write a set of plausible replies to bait them into sending the payload.
    • AndrewKemendo 12 hours ago
      Agreed it’s annoying as hell
  • JustRouzbeh 9 hours ago
    Using a separate email just for HN is good advice. Once your main address is posted in a hiring thread, you can't really take it back
  • usr1106 14 hours ago
    Nothing new there. I also use a different email on every service (and I avoid to give any Email if I can).

    The worst spamming addresses I have closed, but those are really few of the over 1000 addresses in 20 years. My last contribution to the Linux kernel is already 10 years ago (shame on me), but that address is of course public as long Linux exists. Interestingly enough it gets a steady, but very low volume inflow of classical Nigeria letters. Less than once a week. 30,000,000 US Dollars of the late honorable XYZ that can only be salvaged with my help. Too nostalgic to close that address :)

  • tasuki 9 hours ago
    > HN is being scraped for emails to scam

    I'd be more surprised if it weren't...

  • BLKNSLVR 14 hours ago
    On my to-do list is to setup a new domain for throw-away / single use email addresses per site, for this very reason. I would also intend to have a publicly accessible web page that keeps track of which of these emails have been compromised or received spam.

    It's a ways down the list though, but my privacy is increasingly exposed the longer I don't get it done.

  • dataviz1000 13 hours ago
    Yes. I got hit with classic North Korean scam job offer. I am impressed by the sophistication.
    • vconnor 11 hours ago
      I got a few one that didn’t even try to hide it was a scam job offer. They were from people from Asia asking me to work on my behalf, using my name and credentials, for 50% split.
      • tasuki 9 hours ago
        Is that even a scam?
        • zahlman 6 hours ago
          My understanding is that going along with it might entail unwittingly participating in a criminal enterprise.
    • bikvfeee 11 hours ago
      Are you going to leave us hanging?
    • tetrisgm 12 hours ago
      What’s it like
      • dataviz1000 49 minutes ago
        It's like I'm smarter and a more capable developer than people in crypto because I know better than install software for a coding interview on my machine let alone a machine owned by a current employer, yet, when I apply to these crypto companies they still put my resume in the trash.
  • nirui 10 hours ago
    > so I immediately knew that the late AWS payments email sent to my HN email were fake

    Have you ever mentioned AWS on this platform? If you're, then maybe the attack is more targeted/sophisticated than you've imagined.

    • eks391 6 hours ago
      ... I have mentioned working with AWS. I hadn't thought of this, but that does make the scam much scarier if the personalization was intentional
      • nirui 4 hours ago
        Yep, they're might be doing account profiling. Creepy, some might say, it's OSINT level stuff.

        I never posted my email on this platform, but my Keybase page has that info, that's why I have also received few promotional emails originated from my HN posts.

        But regardless, my internal security policy basically forbids me to be a early-bird of anything that require my personal info (that includes the email address), so these emails will never be effective on me.

    • AznHisoka 5 hours ago
      Good thing I never pay my late AWS payments!

      (Its for old deprecated project and i forgot my password and they make you jump through hoops to reset it)

      • nirui 4 hours ago
        Good for you :)

        Though, the scam bots probably won't care about that. They mark your HN account as a AWS user then they send you scam mails hoping to trick you. Their failure is cheap, your failure is (maybe) expensive, that's the formula here.

  • Nemesis-driod 6 hours ago
    but i think if you are educated enough, you will not click on that mail and ignore it mostly. phishing mail will be little problem but mostly we are safe only, managing multiple account for that case is not work.
  • calyhre 11 hours ago
    A bit similar, but I did a Show HN a few weeks ago that did not have much views, yet my contact form got blown out by cold mails trying to sell services to promote it.
    • vortegne 11 hours ago
      Same here! My Show HN completely flopped but I’m still getting emails about services every other day
  • dt3ft 11 hours ago
    Same goes for Show HN.
  • schoenobates 10 hours ago
    It's very annoying - I posted an OSS project and got hit with hundreds of junk emails over the next few weeks from offers to monitise through to fake hosting provider scams. TBH I should have realised something like that would happen, but it was it is now...
  • rl3 12 hours ago
    My solution to this is to never post my e-mail, and to then never really check my e-mail on top of it.

    Defense in-depth.

  • jpardoe 9 hours ago
    Of course.
  • exabrial 11 hours ago
    use icloud relay if you have it!
  • sooraj_sj 14 hours ago
    yes setting up domain is better choice
    • bikvfeee 11 hours ago
      Defends against different things. I think that if your main email on the same domain as your throwaways, be careful how you use your throwaways for.
  • neya 13 hours ago
    Worse than scam is YC's own AI startups scraping your emails and cold emailing you (using AI too) about their product/service. They all sound alike across YC batches too. Makes me think if it's actually taught.
    • teledream 8 hours ago
      I got like 20 emails due to this. If you're gonna pitch me, at least do it in your authentic voice.
    • pixl97 13 hours ago
      >cold emailing you (using AI too)

      So setup your email to watch this with your own AI and have it do a bit of back and forth with made up details and consistent but fake information. Might as well waste their time.

  • syngrog66 12 hours ago
    a "do data labelling microtasks to train coding LLMs to replace you" op has been spamming my inbox around once a day for many weeks now. going to the unique email address I put in my Who Wants To Be Hired comment post here on HN. The emails look automated, template-based. They make superficial tweaks each time.

    and of course to "apply" to their microtasking gig they expect you to submit data labelling work for them, unpaid.

    parasitic scum

    my policy is to quote a very high fee. I win either way.

  • VCFundedGenYer 12 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • wangdream95 6 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • pacertrip 5 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • ciao22 2 hours ago
    [dead]
  • bilalayyah 12 hours ago
    [flagged]