20 comments

  • jesol 116 days ago
    I've been working on a graph database in Rust this year actually! I'd love to hear anything you can talk about wrt the query planner and/or how you decided to do cardinality estimation. I decided to go with an EAV graph which makes CE pretty complex, and it's been an interesting challenge to balance quality and speed and expressiveness in the query language
  • mentioum 116 days ago
    We've been having some issues with intermittent performance on multi hop queries.

    What's your p99 like for multi hops?

    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      In prod we see p99’s of <10ms ms for warm queries and around 50ms per hop for cold queries.
      • mentioum 116 days ago
        Hmmm... I'll get in touch. Got an email i can reach out to, there doesn't seem to be one listed on your website?

        I'm more concerned about if the p99s stay consistent when things get spikey.

        dgraph is fine otherwise...

      • keynha 116 days ago
        [dead]
    • zw17 116 days ago
      If your use case is OLAP based, please check it out PuppyGraph. It’s a graph query engine that sits on top of your Lakehouse (no ETL required). Our benchmark has shown consistently that 10-hop queries across billions of edges in <2 seconds. Our customers including some most data demanding companies like Coinbase, Datadog, Palo Alto Network, Netskope, AMD, etc.
      • mentioum 116 days ago
        It's not, its actually our prod db with direct user usage - we self host a large dgraph cluster. We have a very large number of people manage their car and car histories with us and host a full replica of the UK MOT Database.

        We're fine with clickhouse and redshift for the OLAP work we do. I've been looking at ParaQuery lately if I really want to speed that up.

      • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
        PuppyGraph is a good fit for OLAP for sure.

        We’re just two young founders sharing what we’ve been building, so I’ll take the drive-by competitor plug as a compliment :)

        Definitely a different focus though. Helix is OLTP, built for operational graph + vector workloads, especially apps/agent memory where low-latency traversals and writes are concerned.

    • nulltrace 116 days ago
      [dead]
  • thedreammachine 116 days ago
    What kinds of graph shapes or query patterns do you feel are the worst case for object storage?
    • GeorgeCurtis 115 days ago
      OLAP queries, deep multi-hops where latency is a priority.

      As long as the sub-graph you're trying to hop is cached, then there's no problem or latency issues. However, if you need to do a deep hop query, where all those nodes and edges are in cold storage, each hop costs ~50ms. So a 10-hop would take ~0.5 seconds.

      Again though, we find most people are using us for agentic workloads, so even this worst case scenario the LLMs make up the majority of the latency.

  • rgbrgb 116 days ago
    congrats on the launch! site and docs look great.

    can you host this yourself or do you need to use helix-cloud? the chat thing on the side seems to push me to helix-cloud but it looks like that starts at like $600/mo which is above my experimentation budget.

    looking for a db for an agent memory application and i'd probably start with something that's just self-hosted / freeish. postgres is working ok but I want to start ingesting server and chat logs.

    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      You can definitely host it for free locally for now.

      We aim to launch our GA cloud at the end of this month, which will be much more affordable.

      • Onawa 116 days ago
        Why do you say "for now"?
        • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
          Lapse of communication. For now as in you’ll be able to host it without reading the source code.

          Soon you’ll be able to host it yourself AND have access to the source code

  • cjlm 116 days ago
    Currently #5 on gdb-engines.com - definitely worth a look.
    • dig1 116 days ago
      How rankings are calculated? HelixDB has zero feature scores, unlike e.g. JanusGraph which is at #27 or Neo4j at #1.
      • cjlm 116 days ago
        The feature scores are from a paper cited on the site. The ranking features are proprietary to dissuade gaming but are a blend of open public data across a number of different sources.
    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      yooo this is awesome. Didn't even realise :)
  • caust1c 116 days ago
    Where's the source code for the database itself? Looks like the repo is just a client.

    Congrats on the launch!

    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      This was a TEMPORARY decision we made, and I wrote a bit about why we did this here: https://x.com/georgecurtiss/status/2060043184059912470

      We’re 100% committed to going back to open-source on an Apache 2.0 license as soon as possible. In the meantime, you can continue to deploy us completely for free, however you like, using the compiled docker container.

      • tao_oat 116 days ago
        Unfortunately it's not possible to read this without an X account.
  • let_rec 116 days ago
    This seems like a great idea.

    What reassurance can you offer devs that are hesitant to try a new data-store?

    • GeorgeCurtis 115 days ago
      Can't imagine why they'd be hesitant, Helix is awesome, we've never had any data loss issues, and are completely ACID.

      I'd encourage them to start a local instance with claude/codex to build a mini project and see what it's like.

      • aitchnyu 115 days ago
        Does it work only on S3?
        • GeorgeCurtis 110 days ago
          No, you can run it in-memory or on-disk too
          • aitchnyu 110 days ago
            I mean object stores from other clouds.
            • let_rec 109 days ago
              Probably? Other clouds implement the S3 API
  • ymir_e 116 days ago
    Congrats on the launch George!

    Looking forward to looking into the generalised AI memory layer when it comes out.

  • lennertjansen 115 days ago
    Are you ACID? And does this version have multi-tenancy?
  • maxrumpf 116 days ago
    does it support fts/vector on edges of the graph?
    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      Yes you can put vectors, full text data, secondary and range indexes on both nodes and edges.
  • brene 116 days ago
    How does this compare vs. Turbopuffer?
    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      We see comparable results for vectors and FTS.

      For vector search we have warm and cold p99s of approx 20ms and 400ms respectively. For FTS, warm and cold query p99s of approx 15ms and 250ms respectively.

      Both of these benchmarks were run on 1m docs.

  • rajit 116 days ago
    when will the graph memory layer be available?
    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      We plan on launching end of month.
  • Bnjoroge 116 days ago
    congrats! how does this compare to turbopuffer, surreal or other multi-model ones built on object storage or not
    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      tpuffer is a vector/fts database. Surreal is a bit of an "everything database".

      We're a graph database with vector and FTS capabilities. Our vector and FTS benchmarks are comparable with tpuffer, but you would primarily use us for building whole applications, knowledge graphs, or AI memory/retrieval. Anything that is relationship intense.

      Let me know if this properly answers your question

      • Bnjoroge 115 days ago
        it does, think I misunderstood your value prop. best of luck -definitely a real usecase.
  • raufakdemir 116 days ago
    what language does this support? cypher/gremlin?
    • GeorgeCurtis 116 days ago
      We don't support cypher or gremlin. We can

      You can query HelixDB using JSON or directly in your programming language of choice by using our Rust, TypeScript, Go or Python SDKs. We’ve found AI is very good at working with the SDKs and JSON itself to query, making the development experience much better than before: https://docs.helix-db.com/database/querying

  • AmareshHebbar 114 days ago
    [dead]
  • busraugur 116 days ago
    [flagged]
  • lvca 116 days ago
    [flagged]
  • miningmai 115 days ago
    [dead]
  • sonixaep 115 days ago
    [dead]
  • NexoraDev 116 days ago
    bellissimo