Replace IBM Quantum back end with /dev/urandom

(github.com)

50 points | by pigeons 3 hours ago

3 comments

  • pigeons 3 hours ago
    Project Eleven just awarded 1 BTC for "the largest quantum attack on ECC to date", a 17-bit elliptic curve key recovered on IBM Quantum hardware. Yuval Adam replaced the quantum computer with /dev/urandom. It still recovers the key.
    • logicallee 16 minutes ago
      but does the quantum hardware do it any faster?
      • petterroea 6 minutes ago
        > The author's own CLI recovers every reported private key at statistically indistinguishable rates from the IBM hardware runs.
  • dogma1138 32 minutes ago
    Just to point it out this isn’t a jab at QC but rather a jab at project 11 and possibly the submission author, basically they failed to validate the submission properly and the code proves that the solution is classical.

    Recovering a 17bit ecc key isn’t a challenge for current classical computers via brute force.

    • logicallee 17 minutes ago
      if the solution is faster than random it could still be a real solution on a quantum computer.
    • aaron695 18 minutes ago
      [dead]
  • iberator 8 minutes ago
    Quantum computing is 3 decades old scam. Not even Google was able to prove that their quantum computer works LOL.

    weakened algorithms to the extreme (17 bits in 2026 LOL).