Show HN: Git Push No-Mistakes

(github.com)

15 points | by akane8 1 day ago

4 comments

  • jmagland 3 hours ago
    I like the idea of having a proxy git server between you and the remote, I've never seen that before. Are there other use cases you imagine for such a setup besides intercepting and reviewing pushes?
    • akane8 2 hours ago
      haven't thought of other use yet! would be curious to hear if anyone sees another use case
  • csh0 3 hours ago
    This is interesting, but what is the advantage of running a proxy to achieve this over pre-commit hooks?
    • akane8 2 hours ago
      when the agentic review finds 7 problems and you only care about 4, and want to add some instructions for how the agent should fix them, this kind of interactive back-n-forth is very jarring to do in pre-commit hooks.
  • snehesht 19 hours ago
    Interesting idea, why not run this custom agent as part of PR Review process ?

    Good clean PRs accepted based on score from your customer agent, rest are closed with comments.

    If this is for AI agents to push code, I’d recommend introducing a feedback look from your review agent back to your coding agent.

    • akane8 17 hours ago
      great questions! the goal is to kill as much slop as possible before it becomes a PR and potentially waste other human reviewers’ time.

      the feedback loop does exist and there’s a smooth review->fix loop there

  • ANTHONY6632 20 hours ago
    [dead]