4 comments

  • snvzz 92 days ago
    Appreciate how the article documents the physical side of floppy interface and how a track is selected and read.

    Then there's the (several) formats of tracks and sectors, which are left out of scope.

    Mature open-source alternatives include GreaseWeazle[0] and FluxEngine[1].

    They are also cheap and effective, based on off-the-shelf parts.

    0. https://github.com/keirf/greaseweazle/wiki

    1. https://cowlark.com/fluxengine/index.html

  • asdefghyk 91 days ago
    Would not the best way to scan a deteriorating? floppy disks is with a magnetic flux measuring tool that flies very close to surface of floppy , but not touching the floppy. Recording the analogue signal, generated a require a big storage space .....
  • ThomasBb 92 days ago
    Reminds me of the applesauce project for Apple ][ disks; https://overcast.fm/+BRm0EGSWs
  • jgalt212 92 days ago
    The cheapest Saleae Logic Analyzer costs $499.

    https://www.saleae.com/products/saleae-logic-pro-16

    A Greaseweazle costs like $35.

    That being said, it's always fun to hack around using the tools you have lying around. Put money already spent to good use.

    • hi-v-rocknroll 91 days ago
      Yep. I have a Greaseweazle and a Central Point Copy II PC Deluxe Option Board (and regular). Greaseweazle is largely the way to go. It's important to use the highest-fidelity method on the best FDD with the highest SNR because using a floppy disk causes wear to the media. Age also plays a factor.

      I also have TEAC (2.88M, 1.44M, 1.2M, 720K, 360K, and SCSI versions), Sony, and various other FDDs.

    • nine_k 92 days ago
      If you already have a logic analyzer, are interested in the details, and maybe are facing a tricky disk with physical damage or creative copy protection, TFA may be helpful. If you just need to read disks without hassle and expense, a Greaseweasle or another adapter us likely a more suitable choice.
    • vbezhenar 92 days ago
      There are much cheaper logic analyzers out there.
      • snvzz 92 days ago
        I would suggest as the starting point to look at sigrok's supported hardware table[0].

        I personally own a bunch of the cheap 8ch 24Msps saleae clones, which are typically below $10. I would recommend the one from muselab as it has open sourced its design.

        The next step, the DSLogic, of which I have a 200Msps 16ch model.

        0. https://sigrok.org/wiki/Supported_hardware

        • userbinator 92 days ago
          I would recommend the one from muselab as it has open sourced its design.

          The original Saleae, USBee AX, etc. are basically the Cypress FX2 reference design.

    • rasz 92 days ago